Local
Alamo Square Transitional Housing Proposal Tests SF's Shelter Equity Law
San Francisco supervisors are proposing a 60-bed transitional housing site at Casa Loma near Alamo Square, modeled on the Marina Inn recovery program, as the city's year-old geographic equity ordinance reshapes where homelessness services go. Supporters say it spreads resources more fairly, but advocates warn over 200 shelter beds have closed without replacement.
San Francisco supervisors are proposing a 60-bed transitional housing program at Casa Loma, a hotel at 610 Fillmore St. near Alamo Square Park, for people exiting drug treatment, city officials said. The site would provide housing for roughly 18 to 24 months and is modeled on the Marina Inn, a 68-bed recovery housing program run by the Salvation Army on the city's northern edge that offers case management and on-site services to help residents move into permanent housing.
The city hopes to open Casa Loma by July, pending approval from the Board of Supervisors. The proposal comes a year after San Francisco enacted a geographic equity ordinance barring new city-funded shelters or behavioral health and treatment facilities in neighborhoods with a higher concentration of services than residents who need them.
Supervisor Bilal Mahmood, who represents the Tenderloin, said the ordinance is designed to make every neighborhood contribute.
"The purpose of the geographic equity ordinance was to ensure that every neighborhood is doing more of its fair share to address homelessness, as it is a neighborhood-by-neighborhood issue," Mahmood said.
Under the rule, new shelter beds can be added in the Tenderloin only if need increases or if other services are replaced. "No new shelter can be automatically added into the neighborhood, but if it goes in, it has to swap with something that already exists there," Mahmood said. "We are making sure that we are replacing the things that are less needed with things that the neighborhood needs."
Since the ordinance passed, the city has opened several facilities focused on drug treatment for homeless people with addiction. It has also expanded recovery services, including a behavioral health facility on Treasure Island with more than 120 units, comprising 44 beds in a new residential treatment program and 84 new recovery-housing beds. A separate Treasure Island facility slated to open in 2028 will include 172 existing recovery-housing beds relocated from former U.S. Navy housing.
But several shelters closed around the time the rule took effect, including Jerrold Commons in the Bayview and an abstinence-based shelter called Hope House. Lukas Illa, policy director at the Coalition on Homelessness, said the net loss is severe.
"We're seeing over 200 shelter beds close without replacement, and most of that type of shelter is for single adults," Illa said. "That is severely devastating for the population of folks on the street."
Illa said the city should not offset cuts in one part of the system while pursuing equity in another. "In striving for geographic equity, we should not be supplanting cuts elsewhere to our homeless response system," he said. "We are a very rich city. We need to meet the moment of our behavioral health and affordability crisis that plague our streets. And there is no excuse for shrinking the pot of resources and available shelter units, available housing units."
The debate over where to site shelters and treatment services follows the U.S. Supreme Court's 2024 decision in City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, which allows cities to enforce encampment bans even when shelter is unavailable. It also comes as Mayor Daniel Lurie has prioritized expanding drug treatment beds while the overall number of shelter beds has fluctuated.
Supporters of the equity ordinance say sites like Casa Loma show it is beginning to work by spreading services beyond neighborhoods such as the Tenderloin, Bayview and Mission District that have historically housed a disproportionate share of shelters. The proposal now heads to the Board of Supervisors for approval, with the city aiming for a July opening.