Politics
Rhode Island House Panel Unanimously Backs Matos for Supreme Court Despite Abortion Controversy
The House Judiciary Committee voted unanimously to advance Judge Luis Matos's nomination to the Rhode Island Supreme Court, sending it to the full House after Matos addressed leaked allegations about his past anti-abortion views by affirming he is now pro-choice.
PROVIDENCE â The Rhode Island House Judiciary Committee voted unanimously on Tuesday to approve Judge Luis Matos's appointment to the state Supreme Court, moving his nomination to the full House of Representatives for a vote scheduled for Dec. 1.
Matos, a Superior Court judge and former federal prosecutor, faced scrutiny over leaked emails from a Maryland woman who alleged that in 1994, when they were romantically involved and she became pregnant, he took an extreme anti-abortion stance and refused to help raise the child. The woman did not testify at the hearing.
In response to the allegations, Matos issued a statement and reiterated during the televised hearing that he has personally supported a woman's right to choose for many years, though he acknowledged his views have evolved.
"I have for a long time supported a woman's right to choose and that wasn't always my perspective. I acknowledge that. But that is my perspective today," Matos told lawmakers. He stressed that his personal opinion would not influence his judicial role, saying he has always endeavored to keep his opinions private to maintain impartiality.
The committee heard testimony from a parade of state and federal judges, including Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Suttell, Superior Court Chief Judge Joseph Montalbano, and U.S. District Chief Judge John J. McConnell Jr., who praised Matos's integrity, temperament, and fairness. They highlighted his work on a committee created by the chief justice to ensure racial fairness in the courts following the 2020 murder of George Floyd.
Matos, who immigrated from Portugal at age 5 speaking no English, described his path as an American success story and mentioned that he ran his first marathon at age 60.
Rep. Justine Caldwell, a committee member, raised concerns about gun violence, noting that the Supreme Court will soon take up a bill to ban assault weapons. "I would like to support a candidate for the Supreme Court that believes our General Assembly has the right to pass those bills and to protect Rhode Islanders from gun violence," she said.
House Judiciary Chairwoman Carol McEntee asked Matos directly about his current views on abortion rights, given the repeal of Roe v. Wade and Rhode Island's 2019 codification of abortion protections. Matos affirmed his pro-choice stance but declined to elaborate on how he would rule on specific cases.
The nomination now proceeds to the full House and then the Senate. If confirmed, Matos would fill a vacancy on the five-member Supreme Court.
The hearing also highlighted transparency concerns: House and Senate leaders refused to make public written testimony submitted for or against judicial nominees, citing confidentiality of investigatory packets. However, a letter from the Alliance for Justice supporting Matos was leaked to the press, and retired Judge Edward Clifton read aloud a letter from The Ministers Alliance of Rhode Island praising Matos that legislative leaders had not released.
Matos's confirmation process continues as Rhode Island's courts face upcoming decisions on abortion-related cases and gun legislation, making his judicial philosophy a focal point for lawmakers and advocates alike.