Local
Neronha Seeks to Defend Rhode Island's Clergy Abuse Revival Law as Diocese Challenges It in Court
Attorney General Peter Neronha is asking to join more than 180 lawsuits against the Diocese of Providence to defend a new law that reopened a two-year window for survivors of alleged clergy sexual abuse. The diocese argues the revival law violates the Rhode Island Constitution.
PROVIDENCE â Attorney General Peter Neronha is seeking to intervene in the wave of lawsuits filed against the Diocese of Providence over alleged clergy sexual abuse, aiming to defend the constitutionality of a state law that gave survivors a fresh chance to sue institutions accused of enabling or covering up the abuse.
The law, which took effect July 1, created a two-year window running through June 30, 2028, allowing certain civil claims that had previously expired under the statute of limitations to be brought against alleged abusers and the institutions that employed or supervised them. Thirty-four lawsuits were filed on the window's first day, and more than 180 cases have been filed since, according to Providence Journal reporting.
The Diocese of Providence contends that reviving claims after their filing deadlines had passed violates the Rhode Island Constitution. In a statement, the diocese argued that defendants have a vested right to rely on an expired statute of limitations and that decades-old claims are difficult to defend because evidence and witnesses may no longer be available.
The diocese pointed to prior state Supreme Court precedent, saying the court had ruled unanimously that the Constitution "precludes legislation with retroactive features permitting revival of an already time-barred action." It added that the court will need to address the constitutional question and that plaintiffs, defendants and judges have been working cooperatively toward certification.
Neronha's office argues the issue should first be briefed in Superior Court, giving a judge a fuller record before deciding whether to send the constitutional question directly to the Rhode Island Supreme Court. Whether the question will be certified to the high court remains unresolved.
Courts in other states have split on similar revival laws. Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland and New York have upheld such statutes, and Massachusetts' highest court upheld a retroactive extension in a case that was still pending. Courts in Maine, New Hampshire, Utah and Colorado, by contrast, have ruled that certain revival laws could not be applied to claims whose filing deadlines had already expired. The outcomes often turn on the specific wording of each state's constitution and statute.
The case is being watched closely by survivors and advocates who say the window is a rare opportunity for accountability, and by the diocese and other institutions that warn of open-ended liability. For Rhode Islanders, the dispute will determine whether the more than 180 pending cases can proceed â and whether other institutions named in future claims will face the same revived exposure.