Local
Nationwide Sues U.S. Government Over Providence Crash Involving ICE Agent
Nationwide Insurance is seeking $21,586.64 from the federal government after an ICE agent allegedly ran a red light in an unmarked DHS SUV and T-boned a Providence College student's car. The lawsuit, filed in federal court, highlights questions about accountability when federal agents cause local crashes.
PROVIDENCE, R.I. â Nationwide Insurance has filed a federal lawsuit against the U.S. government over a Providence car crash involving an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent, alleging the agent ran a red light and caused a collision that injured a local college student.
The suit, filed in federal court, identifies an ICE employee who was driving a Department of Homeland Security-owned Ford Expedition when it struck a white BMW at the intersection of Chalkstone Avenue and Raymond Street on Oct. 14, 2025. The filing accuses the driver of "careless and negligent" behavior and seeks $21,586.64 to cover damages and medical benefits Nationwide paid to its insured.
According to a Providence police report, witnesses said the unmarked SUV had its emergency lights activated but no siren was sounding when it went through the red light. Body-worn camera footage from responding officers captured one witness describing the scene: "They ended up going through the red light with their lights on. No siren. Just like only, and then I just saw this white car smack him."
The driver of the white BMW, who identified himself as a Providence College student, told officers that masked agents at the scene focused their attention on the ICE employee rather than checking on him. He said they told him to "settle down," and he recalled telling them, "He just T-boned me."
Nationwide says it paid $19,586.64 for damage to the BMW and $2,000 in medical benefits. The insurer is now seeking to recover those costs from the federal government under the Federal Tort Claims Act, which allows certain claims against the United States for negligent acts of federal employees.
The crash raises broader questions about how federal immigration enforcement operations interact with local communities. Providence police have not publicly commented on the incident beyond the initial report, and ICE did not respond to a request for comment.
The case is one of several recent incidents nationwide in which federal agents have been involved in traffic collisions while on duty, prompting scrutiny from local officials and advocates who argue that unmarked vehicles and emergency responses without sirens can endanger residents.
For the Providence College student, the crash left him dealing with vehicle damage and medical bills, though Nationwide's lawsuit aims to ensure the costs are borne by the government rather than its policyholder. The lawsuit does not specify the exact injuries sustained.
The U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Rhode Island, which typically handles such cases, declined to comment on pending litigation. A court date has not yet been scheduled.