Local
Portland School Board Faces Growing Pressure Over Superintendent's Plan to Close 10 Elementary Schools
Superintendent Kimberlee Armstrong's final recommendation to close 10 elementary schools has drawn fierce opposition from parents and teachers, who say district data shows larger class sizes and no clear staffing benefit. The school board votes Dec. 15.
Portland Public Schools Superintendent Dr. Kimberlee Armstrong has recommended closing 10 elementary schools, a proposal that has ignited fierce opposition from parents and teachers who say the district's own data undermines its promise of better classroom conditions.
At a school board meeting Tuesday night, a crowd packed Benson Polytechnic High School's auditorium, chanting "Save our schools!" at the seven-member board. The board is scheduled to vote on the recommendation Dec. 15, with a Dec. 1 meeting set as the first opportunity for detailed questions.
District officials argue that consolidating buildings would create more comparable learning environments across the district, allowing students to attend well-resourced schools with robust programming. But a 60-page memo accompanying the final recommendation has fueled skepticism, with critics pointing to staffing projections and class-size forecasts that they say contradict the district's stated goals.
A key concern centers on staffing. The Portland Association of Teachers, aided by data-savvy parents, points to a section buried near the end of the memo indicating the district would lose slightly more full-time school employees under the closure plan than under the status quo for the 2027â28 school year. In both scenarios, the district forecasts shedding hundreds of positions due to a $65 million budget hole.
Richard Smith, the district's senior director of data and accountability, acknowledged the district has "struggled to tell our story a bit" on staffing but said the reduction is essentially the same either way. He said the district would cut 243 full-time school positions under the status quo and 253 under the superintendent's recommendation, with about 34.5 positions reallocated in either scenario. Closing schools, he added, would allow the district to realize "programmatic efficiencies" that could spare more educators.
"Families are being promised that closing schools will ensure the remaining schools have more. Educators and families have long asked to see details," said teachers union president Alisha Chavez at a Wednesday press conference. "The data confirms what we've long suspected: The numbers don't add up."
Parents also flagged an attachment detailing allowable uses for reallocated staffâinstructional coaching, academic intervention, school climate support, social work, or duty supportânoting it does not mention adding classroom teachers. Alexis Córdova, an Irvington Elementary parent, said such inconsistencies make it hard to trust the plan.
"Every error in this plan lands in the classroom: fewer adults, bigger classes, and just less room for students in the school," Córdova said. "That's why we're asking the board to vote no on Dec. 15 and pause the closures."
Class-size projections vary by school. While the district says overall class sizes would remain unchanged, individual breakdowns show some students from closing schools would move to receiving schools with significantly larger classes. Buckman Elementary students, for example, would see average class sizes rise from 21 under the status quo to 28.4 at Abernethy and 27 at Sunnyside under the recommendation.
Parents at Rose City Park Elementary worry that Vestal Elementary, slated to receive the Vietnamese dual language immersion program, lacks spaceâonly six classrooms available for a program that needs 12 to function effectively.
McKay Larrabee, a parent who has worked on enrollment forecasting for other districts, warned that the plan assumes families will follow programs to new buildings. If they instead stay at neighborhood schools, receiving schools like Atkinson could be overwhelmed. "Decisions based on inaccurate data create capacity crises that PPS will not be able to easily fix," she said.
Margaret Calvert, the district's executive director of school planning and modernization, said PPS will take inventory in January of where families plan to go after the board vote.
The district acknowledges that even with closures, only half of elementary schools and 47% of middle schools would meet enrollment thresholds for robust programming by 2031â32âfar better than the 18% and 13% that would qualify without closures. The memo also shows that higher percentages of students in poverty, special education students, multilingual learners, and students underserved by race would attend schools meeting those thresholds.
Still, concerns persist about whether the process will serve the district's most vulnerable students, from whether receiving buildings can accommodate special education students to fears among Latino families that concentrating Spanish dual language immersion programs could make them easier targets for federal immigration enforcement.
Multiple board members have begun suggesting amendments based on community feedback, and more questions are expected at the Dec. 1 meeting.