Sports
Philadelphia Marathon Faces Lawsuit Over Exclusion of Nonbinary Runners from Pro Division
Three nonbinary athletes are suing the city and race director, alleging the Philadelphia Marathon's professional division discriminates by requiring runners to register as male or female, denying them equal prize money and elite treatment.
Three nonbinary athletes filed a lawsuit Tuesday against the City of Philadelphia and Philadelphia Marathon race director Kathleen Titus, alleging that the race's professional division discriminates on the basis of gender identity in violation of the Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance. The suit, filed in Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, seeks a ruling that the city violated the ordinance, an order requiring the marathon to end the discriminatory practice, and damages for the three runners.
The athletesâWinter Parts, Reed Williams, and Miche Palmerâhave all previously run in Philadelphia Marathon events. While the marathon has offered a nonbinary registration option in its open division since 2022, runners who wish to compete in the professional division for larger cash prizes, elite accommodations, and prestige must still register as either male or female.
"The Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinances has a very specific protection prohibiting discrimination on the basis of gender identity," said Maia Goodell, the attorney representing the runners.
The lawsuit details the financial and dignitary harms the athletes say they have suffered. Williams placed first in the nonbinary open division in 2024 and received $4,000, while professional division winners took home $10,000. Parts, who first ran the half marathon in 2021 and had to register as male despite identifying as nonbinary, finished as the first nonbinary runner in the 2022 open division but received no prize money, even as the top male and female runners each earned $10,000.
"We're not in this for the money," Parts said. "We're in it for the equality."
The suit also alleges that the marathon's infrastructure has failed to adapt to the nonbinary category. After the 2022 race, Parts said staff directed male athletes one way and female athletes another at the finish line, with no nonbinary option. Fatigued after 26.2 miles, Parts chose to join the men, fearing that joining the women's line would lead some to assume they had registered as a woman to rank highly. "I think a lot of those people don't understand how much mental difficulty we got through in trying to avoid these kind of difficult situation," Parts said. The suit further claims that 2022 race results assigned all nonbinary runners as either male or female, and that Williams witnessed nonbinary runners being misgendered at the finish line the following year.
Local LGBTQ run clubs, including Queer Run and Lez Run, had advocated for a nonbinary professional division for years. They met with Titus ahead of the 2023 race to push for equal benefits, status, and prize money. "We brought up examples from other races. We discussed things like qualifying standards. We tried to address any practical questions that were being raised," said Josh Fernandez, president and executive director of Queer Run. But the marathon declined to open professional registration to nonbinary athletes.
In 2024, the marathon created a path for nonbinary runners to win cash awards in the open division, but the professional division remains restricted to male and female categories. Nearly 120 nonbinary runners participated in races throughout the 2024 marathon weekend, according to city data. The marathon has previously said its professional division policy follows USA Track & Field guidance.
A spokesperson for the Philadelphia Law Department declined to comment, as did Titus through a spokesperson.
Parts and Williams are not running this year's race, which is expected to draw 40,000 participants this weekend. Parts plans to cheer from the sidelines, including for Palmer, who decided to run despite the discrimination. "It's a complicated set of emotions," Parts said. "It sucks that this race is not fully including us."