Sunday, November 22, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Politics

Sotomayor, in Philadelphia, warns that eroding legal norms threaten democracy

Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, accepting the Benjamin Franklin Medal in Philadelphia, said the court's conservative majority has disrupted long-standing norms and that rushed emergency rulings leave justices 'not being fully informed.'

Sotomayor, in Philadelphia, warns that eroding legal norms threaten democracy

Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor warned Friday that a pattern of disrupted legal norms is stripping away protections she considers essential to American democracy, speaking in Philadelphia after receiving the Benjamin Franklin Medal from the American Philosophical Society.

Sotomayor, who has repeatedly dissented as the court's 6-3 conservative majority has overturned precedents, told society members that appellate opinions too often read like "law review articles" detached from the people whose lives they decide. "Very few of them are talking about what's at the center of every case, which is the people involved," she said.

The justice pointed to the 2024 ruling granting former presidents broad immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts, a decision stemming from indictments tied to the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol. Sotomayor dissented alongside Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, arguing the majority reshaped the presidency and undermined the principle that no one is above the law.

"What we've had is a series of norms being disrupted," Sotomayor said. "And without those norms, we're removing protections that I think are critical to how we have functioned so successfully for 250 years."

She also criticized the court's decision overturning a 1935 precedent that had limited presidential power to remove members of the Federal Trade Commission, describing the unitary executive theory behind it as "a legal theory on steroids that has just gone off the rails." The court has separately overturned Roe v. Wade, weakened the Voting Rights Act and expanded presidential authority, she noted.

Sotomayor said not every ruling was wrong. She welcomed decisions pushing back on the president's tariffs and upholding birthright citizenship. "There are things to be celebrated, and there's no question that some rulings were the right rulings," she said. "Were they all for the right reasons? I don't know."

She reserved particular concern for the court's growing reliance on its emergency docket, deciding cases before lower courts have fully examined them. "That is bad for us as a court, because we are making decisions without being assured that all of the relevant legal questions have been actually fully explored," Sotomayor said. "It is important before the court is making a final decision that we are fully informed, and we're not being fully informed and we're making rushed judgments."

The medal, established in 1906, recognizes distinguished public service and has gone to figures including Nelson Mandela, Marie Curie and Bryan Stevenson. Sotomayor, a former prosecutor and district court judge, spoke in conversation with retired appellate judge David S. Tatel during the society's three-day autumn general meeting. Founded by Benjamin Franklin in 1743, the society promotes research in the humanities and sciences.

More from The Philadelphia Focal