Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Politics

Philadelphia Council Committee Votes to End Trash Burning in Chester, Strikes Reworld from Waste Contracts

A Philadelphia City Council committee amended Mayor Cherelle Parker's waste disposal plan to remove Reworld Waste LLC, the company that burns the city's trash in Chester, setting up a full council vote as early as Dec. 3. The move follows testimony from Chester officials and health advocates who called the incinerator a case of environmental racism.

Philadelphia Council Committee Votes to End Trash Burning in Chester, Strikes Reworld from Waste Contracts

A Philadelphia City Council committee voted Wednesday to strip Reworld Waste LLC from a package of new trash disposal contracts, a decision that could end the city's longstanding practice of sending its waste to an incinerator in Chester.

The Committee on the Environment amended an ordinance authorizing Mayor Cherelle Parker's Department of Sanitation to sign three new waste disposal contracts, removing Reworld from the bill. The full City Council must approve the amended legislation before it takes effect. A final vote could come as early as Dec. 3.

"We have ended our practice of burning trash in Chester," said Councilmember Jamie Gauthier, who chairs the environment committee and has pushed to bar the city from signing new contracts for waste incineration.

The vote drew cheers from a crowd that filled the hearing room, with supporters holding signs reading "Incineration kills" and "We deserve clean air."

The contracts at issue would govern the city's curbside trash disposal for the next four to seven years. Along with Reworld, the sanitation department proposed a contract with landfill operator WM, which already handles city trash, and a new contract with landfill operator Republic Services. The city's current waste disposal contracts expire at the end of the year.

Opponents of the Reworld contract argued that pollution from the Chester facility endangers residents' health.

"I have not seen a clearer case of environmental racism, and we ought to call it for what it is," Councilmember Nicolas O'Rourke said during Wednesday's hearing.

Witnesses called to testify, including public officials and advocates from Chester, urged council members to reject the Reworld contract.

Kristin Motley, Chester's health commissioner, said residents of her city suffer from disproportionately higher rates of childhood asthma, infant mortality, cancer and heart disease compared to the national average.

"I'm not suggesting that the trash incinerator is a cause of every illness in Chester, but I am saying that it's a major contributor to pollution," Motley said.

Dr. Walter Tsou, former health commissioner for the city of Philadelphia and a board member of Physicians for Social Responsibility Pennsylvania, said burning plastic waste produces pollutants including particulate matter, nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds.

"Known lung irritants that can trigger asthma, nosebleeds and coughing spells," Tsou said. "What is not measured are dioxins, PFAS, formaldehyde and other chemicals that are known carcinogens."

Chester Mayor Stefan Roots said he wants to see Reworld leave his city, arguing the company is holding back economic development along the waterfront.

"I care about the health of my people," Roots said. "It's time for this to end."

Reworld employees defended the Chester facility. Jyoti Agarwal, director of environmental programs at Reworld, said the company commissioned a third-party health risk assessment that showed risks are "well below thresholds of concern."

John Scott, a lobbyist for Reworld, urged the committee to advance the contract. "A vote yes is a vote for working families, responsible decision making and Philadelphia's future," Scott said.

Parker administration officials testified in support of keeping Reworld in the package. Philadelphia Sanitation Commissioner Crystal Jacobs Shipman said city contractors compared the environmental impacts of landfilling and incineration and found both methods have "flaws."

"The impacts are different, but the cumulative effects are nearly equal," Shipman said. "Both systems equally present challenges for respective host communities for both types of disposal facilities."

Carlton Williams, the city's managing director, said the administration reviewed air quality data from Chester, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Camden County, New Jersey, and New Castle County, Delaware, and found Chester's number of unhealthy air quality days in recent years to be comparable to those other areas.

"If anything, the air quality in Chester is equal to or better than Philadelphia and the surrounding areas," Williams said, as audience members booed. "The data also do not indicate that the Reworld plant is causing spikes in bad air quality."

Casey Kuklick, deputy director of the Office of Clean and Green Initiatives, said the city analyzed Reworld's emissions of nitrogen oxide, sulfur dioxide, volatile organic compounds and particulate matter and found they have decreased over time.

Shipman said that while the city weighed environmental impacts, cost and operational considerations were most important in its decision. Williams estimated that if the city stopped sending trash to Reworld and used landfills only, it would pay roughly $15 million more over the four-year contracts.

"That is still real taxpayer dollars," Williams said.

Gauthier countered that the city is projected to save $28 million over the proposed four-year contracts compared with current contracts, meaning it would still save money even with the additional landfill cost.

"My office has done the math," Gauthier said. "It has never been more urgent, and we have never been better equipped to end Philly's dirty deal with trash incinerators once and for all."

During a press conference this summer, Scott McGrath, environmental planning director for Philadelphia's sanitation department, said a city contractor determined that the sustainability of landfilling and incineration are "essentially equal." That contractor did not compare the three companies' emissions of unhealthy or toxic air pollutants, but rated incinerators in general as more harmful than landfills for human health risks and toxicity.

"The administration's own analysis says incineration is worse for human health," Gauthier said.

The city found Reworld's emissions to be below its state permit, despite the company receiving multiple violations in recent years.

The amended bill now heads to the full City Council, where members could vote as early as Dec. 3. If approved, the legislation would end Philadelphia's practice of shipping its trash to the Chester incinerator, a victory for environmental justice advocates who have long argued that the facility disproportionately burdens a majority-Black city with pollution from waste generated elsewhere.

More from The Philadelphia Focal