Politics
Pennsylvania Bill Would Ban PFAS-Laced Pesticides After Two-Year Phase-Out
State Rep. Tarik Khan has introduced legislation to prohibit the sale and use of pesticides containing PFAS chemicals, citing contaminated waterways and a fish-consumption advisory on Wissahickon Creek. The bill faces pushback from pest-control professionals who warn that alternatives may not be ready in time.
Pennsylvania lawmakers are moving to eliminate a lesser-known source of PFAS contamination: pesticides. A bill introduced by state Rep. Tarik Khan, D-Philadelphia, would ban the sale and use of pesticides containing the toxic "forever chemicals" after a two-year phase-out period.
The legislation arrives as PFAS has been detected in waterways throughout the Philadelphia region. Earlier this year, Pennsylvania health officials warned anglers not to eat fish from Wissahickon Creek after testing found elevated PFAS levels in fish tissue.
"This is one of many bills that we are introducing to protect our environment," Khan said. "[Pesticides are] just another one of those points of exposure, because it is being sprayed on crops, and, of course, that's getting right into our water supply."
Khan said he was prompted to act in part by the Environmental Protection Agency's approval earlier this year of three pesticide products considered to contain forever chemicals, even though they fall outside the agency's narrow definition of PFAS. "We have to make sure that we are protecting our crops, we're protecting our people, but avoiding these unnecessary chemicals that are added that are poisoning our people," he said.
Under the bill, PFAS pesticide use would be prohibited over two years at schools, day cares, health care facilities and on residential lawns, and for commercial mosquito spraying. The agriculture secretary could grant annually reviewed exemptions only for "unavoidable uses" deemed essential to health, safety or society where no reasonable alternatives exist.
The measure is part of a broader push in Harrisburg. Lawmakers introduced separate legislation this year to ban PFAS in household products such as dental floss, children's bedding and playmats, and cosmetics. Gov. Josh Shapiro has also signed a law banning firefighting foam containing PFAS.
PFAS chemicals are widely used in consumer goods including nonstick cookware and waterproof clothing, and have been linked to serious health problems such as some cancers, thyroid disease and developmental delays in children. The compounds can persist in the environment and in human blood for years, spurring numerous lawsuits against manufacturers including DuPont.
The Center for Biological Diversity has found that 14% of all conventional pesticide active ingredients are now PFAS. But the chemicals are not uniform: thousands of types exist, varying widely in toxicity and how they accumulate in living things. The fluorinated compounds in some pesticides differ chemically from the PFAS that have commonly tainted drinking water supplies across the region, and the EPA's narrower definition means many pesticide products are not classified by the agency as forever chemicals. The agency argues these compounds do not persist to the same degree as chemicals like PFOS and PFOA. Some also appear in everyday products such as Frontline, a flea treatment for dogs.
"It's not like PFOA and PFOS and all these other types of chemicals are added directly into pesticides. That's not the case, and I think that's where that's a little bit of a misconception," said Andrew Patterson, a microbiologist and professor at Penn State University. Patterson noted that some pesticide formulations are designed to be applied at lower levels or less frequently, reducing crop losses for farmers.
Environmentalists and scientists counter that these pesticides break down into other persistent pollutants in water supplies.
Marty Overline, president of Aardvark Pest Management in Philadelphia and a member of the state's pest advisory board, said federal and state rules already minimize pesticide risks and that pest-control professionals try several methods before turning to chemicals. He worries a ban could take effect before effective alternatives reach the market, particularly for controlling cockroaches and termites.
"I go into people's homes that have roaches. That's the No. 1 cause of asthma in this country," Overline said. "If I don't have the products to get rid of that, I would think maybe there's going to be more kids that are going to suffer from asthma."
The bill's fate is uncertain in a divided legislature, but its introduction signals growing pressure to address PFAS exposure at the state level as federal rules remain contested.