Politics
Federal Civil Rights Office Opens Third Antisemitism Probe of Philadelphia Schools, Citing 'Sharp Increase' in Harassment Reports
The U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights launched its third investigation of the Philadelphia School District in under three years, alleging the district violated a 2024 voluntary settlement on antisemitism. District officials call the probe politically motivated and say they have received little communication from federal officials.
The U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights has opened a third federal investigation into the Philadelphia School District over alleged antisemitism, federal officials announced Monday, escalating a years-long conflict that district leaders say is driven by politics rather than a genuine assessment of school safety.
The new probe, announced Nov. 16, cites a "sharp increase" in reports of antisemitic harassment in Philadelphia public schools and alleges the district has failed to protect Jewish students from discrimination. The announcement did not describe any specific incidents.
"Just two years after a resolution agreement with the Office for Civil Rights, disturbing allegations against the School District of Philadelphia suggest it continues to abdicate its legal and moral responsibilities to protect students from discrimination and harassment," Kimberly Richey, assistant secretary for civil rights, said in a statement. "The Trump Administration will always fight to protect the dignity, respect, and educational opportunity of our nation's Jewish students."
The investigation is the third federal probe of the district in less than three years and follows a Republican-led House Education and Workforce Committee report last month that concluded some district employees promoted anti-Israel views the committee characterized as antisemitic and attempted to indoctrinate students with "far-left" ideas in the youngest grades. The committee specifically criticized curriculum that teaches second graders about environmental justice and "the impact of bias, injustice and privilege on a global scale."
Superintendent Tony B. Watlington Sr. testified on Capitol Hill earlier this fall. The committee has investigated antisemitism claims against multiple school districts and colleges, including the University of Pennsylvania, since 2023.
In 2024, the district â the nation's ninth-largest school system â entered into a voluntary settlement with the Education Department addressing antisemitism claims, pledging better record-keeping and training for staff and students on anti-discrimination policies.
District spokesperson Naima DeBrest said officials were "very disappointed" in the new investigation, "particularly since the District has been keeping OCR apprised of our significant efforts to implement the Voluntary Resolution Agreement and combat antisemitism and all forms of hate in our schools, including recent communication."
DeBrest said the district has received "very little feedback or acknowledgement" from OCR and that the office "made no outreach to the District to ask questions" after the congressional investigation before Monday's announcement.
"We reiterate that antisemitism has no place in our schools, and we take concerns about antisemitic harassment or discrimination very seriously," DeBrest said. "The district does not tolerate harassment or discrimination against any ethnic, racial or religious group, or against any protected class."
The investigation could conclude in several ways: it could be closed for insufficient evidence; it could end in another voluntary settlement, as the 2024 probe did, avoiding an admission of legal liability while agreeing to monitoring and remedial actions; or, absent a settlement, the district could face administrative proceedings that might result in the loss of federal funds or a federal lawsuit brought by the Justice Department.
The probe lands at a charged moment for the district, which is attempting to fire Ismael Jimenez, who directs its social studies curriculum. Watlington revealed Jimenez's termination proceedings at the congressional hearing, where he also said he had ordered a review of some teachers' social media posts and that the district was moving away from a locally written social studies curriculum developed under Jimenez.
Jimenez was praised over a dozen years as a district social studies teacher before being promoted twice. After the Oct. 7, 2023, attack on Israel and the start of the war between Israel and Hamas, some Jewish families and outside organizations began lodging complaints about his personal social media posts, objecting to them as antisemitic and anti-Israel.
Jimenez has said his critiques target the Israeli government, not Jewish people. He has described the district's move to fire him as "appeasing the authoritarian and the fascist tendencies that the Trump administration made possible, that embolden demagoguery of these politicians who are using claims of antisemitism to stifle any type of critical history, critical social studies." He remains suspended without pay while termination proceedings are pending.
At last month's school board meeting, multiple educators and parents addressed what they believe is district capitulation to federal pressure.
"It is not hard to see that 'the powers that be' are scared, that accusations of 'antisemitism' and 'discrimination' are being used as ammo in their backlash to positive changes and reforms that have taken place in public education, especially since 2020," district teacher Shaw MacQueen said in written testimony.
The new investigation raises questions about the balance between protecting students from harassment and preserving the independence of public school curricula â a tension that has played out in districts across the country as federal and congressional pressure on K-12 education has intensified.