Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Local

Vineland Data Center Noise Lawsuit Cleared to Proceed as Judge Denies Dismissal

A New Jersey Superior Court judge refused to dismiss a class-action lawsuit accusing a Vineland hyperscale data center of disrupting residents' lives with constant humming and buzzing. The ruling allows up to 1,000 nearby residents to pursue noise-abatement and compensation claims against DataOne.

Vineland Data Center Noise Lawsuit Cleared to Proceed as Judge Denies Dismissal

A New Jersey Superior Court judge has denied a motion to dismiss a class-action lawsuit against a hyperscale data center in Vineland, allowing residents who say they are tormented by constant mechanical noise to press their claims in court.

Judge James Swift ruled this week that the allegations against DataOne, the developer of a 300-megawatt facility built to support artificial intelligence infrastructure, constitute a public nuisance and that the company has a duty to mitigate noise. Swift also rejected the defense's request to strike the class-action component, dismissing their argument that because noise does not travel uniformly, the case would require 1,000 separate mini-trials.

The lawsuit alleges that DataOne has failed to soundproof the data center's engines and cooling systems. Residents describe the noise as a hovering helicopter or a loud lawn mower, saying it disrupts sleep, causes stress, and prevents them from enjoying their yards. Three residents living near the facility are named as plaintiffs, but attorney Laura Sheets said up to 1,000 residents within 1.5 miles of the data center could be eligible for the class. She believes the case is among the first of its kind in the United States.

"At the end of this case, we want the noise to stop. We want proper noise abatement," Sheets said. "And we want [residents] to be compensated. We are alleging that not only is it interfering, for the last year and a half, with their ability to use and enjoy their property, but that it's causing major damage to their property values."

Tiffany Leone-Vespa, who lives about a mile from the facility but is not named in the complaint, said the sounds have become so intense that they vibrate her house. She keeps her windows closed and has hired a landscaper to mow her lawn so she can avoid going outside. Still, she said, the noise distracts her during the day and keeps her awake at night.

"We're like prisoners inside the house," Leone-Vespa said. "I hear it all day long, I go to sleep with it, and then wake up to it again in the middle of the night."

Ryan Suppi, who lives about 1.5 miles away and hopes to be included in the class, likened the sound to a loud lawn mower that prevents him from getting adequate sleep.

"I've been there 19 years. My kids grew up there. It's been a quiet, peaceful place and we want it to go back to that way," Suppi said. "If I play loud music at 11 o'clock at night, the police are going to come to my house and tell me I have to turn it off. It should be no different for any company after a certain hour."

Defense attorneys Mark Makhail and Ben Klein argued during the hearing that residents are experiencing temporary construction noises that amount to a mere annoyance, and that until construction is complete it cannot be determined whether the sounds are unreasonable. Makhail declined a request for comment after the ruling. Although the facility remains under construction, at least three data rooms operate around the clock, according to the lawsuit.

Sheets said she believes the metallic noises residents are hearing come from 62 natural gas-powered generators. Last month, New Jersey environmental regulators fined DataOne more than $1 million for operating those generators without a permit. Natural gas generators emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, and other combustion-related pollutants.

DataOne has said the engines will be replaced with Bloom Energy fuel cells, which convert natural gas into electricity through an electrochemical reaction and are described by the company as much quieter and less polluting. The installation timeline is unclear.

A couple dozen residents attended the hearing in person, with others joining virtually. Stefanie Bartiromo, who is not mentioned in the complaint but hopes to be included in the class, said she loves her home of nearly 20 years but is weighing whether to leave because of the noise and potential environmental impact.

"I want to be able to enjoy my house. I didn't plan on moving, but if it gets worse, I might have to," Bartiromo said. "You're stuck in limbo. You want to improve your house, but should I put money into it if I'm just going to be forced out?"

The defense must now file an answer to the allegations, and both sides will begin exchanging evidence as the case moves forward.

More from The Philadelphia Focal