Sunday, November 22, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Local

Philadelphia School District Seeks $11 Million More for Substitute Teachers After Cutting 200+ Positions

The School District of Philadelphia, which eliminated over 200 building substitute positions to save $13 million, now wants an additional $11 million for substitute staffing services. The request raises questions about whether the cuts are delivering promised savings and whether schools are struggling to cover teacher absences.

Philadelphia School District Seeks $11 Million More for Substitute Teachers After Cutting 200+ Positions

The School District of Philadelphia is asking the school board for an additional $11 million to cover substitute staffing costs, less than a year after officials eliminated more than 200 building substitute positions to save $13 million and help close a $300 million budget deficit.

At Thursday's school board meeting, the district requested approval of a contract amendment that would award ESS Northeast LLC an additional $11 million "to maintain essential substitute staffing services in the absence of employees across all District schools." The board approved the amendment unanimously without discussion.

The contract language states the extra funding is needed through November 2026 due to the "elimination of Building Substitute positions." The additional money would bring the district's total contract with ESS to $169.5 million through June 2027.

Superintendent Tony Watlington and Chief Financial Officer Mike Herbstman announced the cuts last March, saying the elimination of building substitutes would save $13 million. Building substitutes were assigned to specific schools and provided stability by covering absences regularly, but the district argued the positions were too costly.

Advocates, including the public school advocacy group Lift Every Voice Philly, warned at the time that eliminating the positions would disrupt classrooms and strain teachers. On Thursday, the group said the bill has come due.

"At this rate, eliminating building substitutes could cost more than if we had kept them," said Shanée Garner, executive director of Lift Every Voice. "We warned that eliminating these positions would strain schools already struggling with staffing shortages."

District data provided to the board shows that for the past four school years, there have been more requests for substitutes than the district could fill, though the fill rate has improved. In November 2022-23, the district filled 505 of 924 substitute requests, or nearly 55%. By November 2025-26, it filled 700 of 938 requests, or about 75%. The district has not provided data for the current 2026-27 school year.

Board members Cheryl Harper and Joyce Wilkerson noted in a question-and-answer document that the $11 million is "a huge amount you're asking for." District spokespeople did not respond to requests for comment.

The request raises new questions about whether the elimination of building substitute positions is delivering the promised savings, and whether schools are now paying more to fill absences through a staffing agency. The district's contract with ESS has grown to $169.5 million through June 2027, a figure that includes the new $11 million amendment.

For families and teachers, the stakes are high: substitute coverage is essential to keeping classrooms staffed when teachers are absent. The district's ability to fill requests has improved, but the need for additional funding suggests the cuts have not solved the underlying staffing challenges.

More from The Philadelphia Focal