Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Local

Judge Backs 718-Home Exton Square Mall Redevelopment; West Whiteland Vows Appeal

A Chester County judge ruled Friday that Abrams Realty & Development may proceed with a 718-home town center at the shuttered Exton Square Mall, finding the township 'manifestly abused its discretion' in rejecting the plan. West Whiteland supervisors say they will appeal, prolonging an 11-month legal fight over the 75-acre site.

Judge Backs 718-Home Exton Square Mall Redevelopment; West Whiteland Vows Appeal

WEST WHITELAND, Pa. — A Chester County judge has cleared the way for a sweeping redevelopment of the former Exton Square Mall, ruling Friday that the township's rejection of a 718-home town center was an abuse of discretion. But the legal battle is far from over: two West Whiteland supervisors who voted against the project said they intend to appeal.

Judge Sarah Black sided with Abrams Realty & Development, which bought the 75-acre mall property last year for $34.25 million and sued the township after its Board of Supervisors refused to approve the mixed-use plan. In her ruling, Black wrote that the township "manifestly abused its discretion" and failed to back up its objections with substantial evidence.

"It is absurd to demand that Plaintiff explain why compliance with the zoning ordinance is in the best interests of the township," Black wrote, according to the Philadelphia Business Journal, which obtained the decision.

The ruling caps an 11-month legal fight over the future of a retail site that has anchored central Chester County for more than half a century. The mall, long underperforming, closed in June after a 53-year run.

Abrams' proposal envisions a walkable town center on the site near the busy intersection of Routes 30 and 100. The plan calls for a 381-unit apartment building, 172 townhomes and a 165-unit building for older adults, along with 167,000 square feet of commercial space, 49,000 square feet of office space and a fitness and entertainment center. Most of the existing mall would be demolished; the Boscov's store would remain and be folded into the new development, and a new building would be constructed for Main Line Health, which still operates next to the shuttered Macy's.

The township's planning commission had recommended approval, but the Board of Supervisors rejected the plan last year, citing inadequate sewer capacity, traffic congestion and strain on police and emergency services. The denial came shortly after the township updated its zoning to cap housing density in the district covering the mall — an ordinance adopted two days after Abrams submitted its application. The developer argued its plan complied with the zoning in effect at the time of submission and that the rejection was politically motivated, costing the company financially while the property sat in limbo.

Supervisors Brian Dunn and Rajesh Kumbhardare, who both voted against the project, said Monday they expect the fight to continue.

"We're pursuing our legal options," Dunn said. "The board intends to appeal the decision."

Kumbhardare said the township is reviewing the ruling. "I have always been, and will continue to be, a strong advocate for doing what I believe is in the best interest of our township and its residents," he said. "I will not hesitate to stand up and fight for our community when I believe a decision does not serve its best interests. Our residents deserve nothing less."

Abrams Realty did not respond to a request for comment. Company owner Peter Abrams told the Business Journal he was grateful for the ruling. "Justice has been served," he said. "All we want to do is to create an elite level project for the people of Chester County."

Even if construction begins, the project could face further delays from continued litigation. Before Abrams bought the property, the township had discussed a different redevelopment with previous owner PREIT that included more commercial space and roughly 300 homes. Abrams later revised its own plan during the planning review, cutting 73 townhomes and adding space for public events.

The decision lands in a region grappling with a severe housing shortage and rising rents, and it highlights a broader tension between local control and the need for more homes near jobs and transit. Supporters of the project say the site's proximity to major roads and its existing infrastructure make it a sensible place to add housing; opponents worry about density, traffic and public services.

For now, the case returns to the courts, with the township's appeal expected to determine whether the town center can break ground or will remain tied up for months to come.

More from The Philadelphia Focal