Monday, November 16, 2026·Focal News

The Philadelphia Focal

Philadelphia's independent voice

Local

Drexel President Testifies Academy Board Weighed Moving 19 Million Specimens to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi

Drexel President Antonio Merlo told City Council that the Academy of Natural Sciences' board proposed closing its Philadelphia museum and relocating its entire collection abroad or out of state, and that Drexel rejected the plan. The testimony came as Council investigates the museum's September closure and the stalled disaffiliation talks between the two institutions.

Drexel President Testifies Academy Board Weighed Moving 19 Million Specimens to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi

PHILADELPHIA — The Academy of Natural Sciences' board and executive leadership floated a plan to permanently close its Philadelphia museum and move its entire collection of 19 million items to Cleveland or Abu Dhabi, Drexel University President Antonio Merlo testified Monday before City Council.

Merlo said the proposal surfaced at an Academy board retreat in September 2025, where leaders described the closure of the public museum as "unpreventable and inevitable." He said he rejected the idea outright.

"I made it clear this was unacceptable and Drexel wanted no part of any plan to remove the Academy's treasures from the City of Philadelphia," Merlo told the Committee on Legislative Oversight. "I told them they would need to disaffiliate from Drexel to move forward with that."

The hearing was the second convened by Council to examine the shutdown of the nearly two-century-old museum on the Benjamin Franklin Parkway at the end of September. Merlo did not appear at the first session in late October, sending an administrator instead; Council responded by subpoenaing him and Deputy Mayor Patricia Wellenbach.

Drexel submitted confidential Academy board minutes along with planning and financial documents that outlined the behind-the-scenes steps toward closing the building and dispersing the collection as the institution coped with persistent deficits.

The relocation plans never materialized, but the episode has become central to a broader dispute over the Academy's future. Drexel has said it can no longer absorb the Academy's operating losses while managing its own budget shortfall, and gave the Academy a choice: merge fully into the university or disaffiliate. The Academy chose to disaffiliate, but the two sides remain deadlocked over the terms of Drexel's financial support in the years after separation. No talks have been held since early October.

Merlo said Drexel has provided nearly $95 million in funding and in-kind contributions to the Academy since the 2011 affiliation agreement. He also described a counterproposal in which Drexel would house the collections, integrate the Academy's research and education mission into the university, and preserve its public programming through exhibits on campus or at a partner museum. Under that plan, Drexel would assume the Academy's assets and liabilities, the board would become advisory, and proceeds from any sale of the Parkway building — estimated at $30 million — would be dedicated entirely to caring for the collections.

In March 2026, Gov. Josh Shapiro asked former Comcast executive and U.S. Ambassador to Canada David L. Cohen to try to broker an agreement. Cohen wrote at the time that the governor's primary goal was to ensure the Academy and its resources did not leave Pennsylvania, according to Merlo.

In early September, the two sides agreed to terms that Merlo said closely resembled Drexel's proposal and included closing the museum. He described the deal as one that "would have secured a financially sustainable future" for the Academy in Philadelphia.

"Drexel was all in on the deal," Merlo said. "So was the mayor. So was the governor. But the Academy's trustees walked away from that deal."

Suzanne Biemiller, who has chaired the Academy board since March 2025, told reporters last week that the board concluded the term sheet "did not work economically" and would not be approved. She said Drexel's initial rejection of a William Penn Foundation offer to fund operating expenses and keep the museum open signaled that the university was not acting in the Academy's best interest.

Merlo said building a sustainable operating model for the Academy will require "tens of millions" of dollars, including major capital repairs, dependable operating support and a museum program that draws visitors back. He said Drexel will honor the 2011 affiliation agreement and is participating in a review funded by the William Penn Foundation and other philanthropies to assess the Academy's physical and financial condition and chart a sustainable path forward.

"Drexel is ready to do its part," he said.

Merlo also apologized for his absence at the October hearing, explaining he was on campus for a meeting with the university's accreditor, and said he regretted how the museum closure was announced.

"It is now clear that this process would have benefited from including City Council members, foundations, and other civic leaders much sooner into the conversation over our efforts to address the Academy's dire financial condition," he testified.

Wellenbach, appointed interim senior advisor of the Academy in early September, told the committee she has "no decision-making over the museum's future" and was not involved in the events leading to the closure. Her role ends in December.

"My operational role is narrow, and my tenure is intended to be brief," she said. "My primary focus is on ensuring continuity during the transition and to serve as a bridge for the Academy while a full-time interim leader is identified."

The governor's office and the mayor's office did not respond to requests for comment.

More from The Philadelphia Focal