Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Nashville Focal

Nashville's independent voice

Politics

Tennessee Voucher Program Reaches 93 Counties, But Wealthy ZIP Codes Still Get One in Five Scholarships

Tennessee's Education Freedom Scholarship program has spread to 93 of 95 counties in its second year, but state data show the same 10 urban and suburban counties still received about 74% of scholarships and the state's 20 wealthiest ZIP codes accounted for roughly one in five awards. Incomplete income and prior-enrollment data leave lawmakers unable to determine whether the program is reaching families who could not otherwise afford private school.

Tennessee Voucher Program Reaches 93 Counties, But Wealthy ZIP Codes Still Get One in Five Scholarships

Tennessee's private school voucher program has spread to more counties in its second year, but state data show scholarships remain heavily concentrated in the state's largest urban and suburban counties and in its wealthiest communities, raising questions about whether the program is reaching the families it was pitched to help.

The Education Freedom Scholarship program awarded 35,000 scholarships in its second year, up from 20,000 in its first, and recipients were reported in 93 of Tennessee's 95 counties, according to Department of Education data. Yet the same 10 counties with the state's highest private school enrollment — Davidson, Shelby, Knox, Hamilton, Rutherford, Williamson, Madison, Sumner, Maury and Montgomery — received about 74% of scholarships in year two, down only modestly from roughly 77% in year one.

Those 10 counties received 26,013 scholarships in the second year, compared with 15,322 in the first. That means they absorbed roughly 71% of the 15,000 new scholarships the state added statewide. Rural counties received only about one in 13 of the added awards.

An analysis of ZIP code data found that Tennessee's 20 wealthiest ZIP codes accounted for approximately one out of every five scholarships in both years. The measure reflects where recipients live rather than individual household income, but the consistent share suggests some of the state's most affluent communities continue to receive a significant portion of the program's benefits.

House Speaker Cameron Sexton, R-Crossville, said the program is beginning to reach rural communities, pointing to Cumberland County, where he said the number of scholarship recipients grew from a handful to roughly 35 or 40.

"I think over the next several years, you'll see more and more rural communities having a choice," Sexton said.

Asked about the one-in-five share going to the wealthiest ZIP codes, Sexton defended the program's design. "One out of five, that's 20%. Let's see how it goes over time as you get into those rural areas and have more opportunities to get there," he said. "I don't think you should penalize families over their success, though."

Jenny Mills McFerron of EdTrust Tennessee, an education advocacy organization, said participation remains uneven because many smaller communities lack private schools to use the vouchers.

"Smaller communities, rural communities don't have private schools to be able to take advantage of the program," McFerron said. "But tax dollars from those communities are still funding the program."

She also questioned whether the program is directing enough resources toward students with the greatest financial need. "It's highly concentrated in wealthy communities of our state," she said. "So, it's not aligning funding with where student need is the greatest."

The state's second-year data leave significant gaps. The Department of Education provided income-related figures for only 10,301 recipients — 2,506 in a category tied to the federal free- and reduced-price lunch threshold, 7,487 within 300% of that threshold and 308 above it — far short of the roughly 35,000 scholarships reflected in other department tables. The department has not provided a complete income breakdown, and its records do not explain how the figures relate to the broader recipient totals.

Another unresolved question is whether scholarship students previously attended public school, private school or were homeschooled. Sexton said last year the state would begin collecting that information, but in response to a public records request for the second year, the Department of Education said it had no additional records providing a separate breakdown. The department said the Tennessee Public Records Act does not require it to create a new record or sort existing records to answer the request.

Without that accounting, taxpayers cannot readily determine how many recipients moved from public schools into private schools and how many were already enrolled in private school before receiving state assistance.

The department reported receiving 56,440 applications for the 2026-27 school year, compared with more than 42,800 in the first year. Sexton has cited strong demand as a reason to expand the program, but application volume alone does not establish whether the program is improving academic outcomes or reaching students who otherwise would lack access to private school.

Applications for the program's third year open next month. Renewal applications for the 2027-28 school year open at noon Central Time on Dec. 8, and applications for new students open at noon on Jan. 12, 2027. The window for all students closes at 4 p.m. on Jan. 29. Students who applied last year but did not receive a scholarship will be treated as new applicants and can apply beginning Jan. 12.

Gov.-elect Marsha Blackburn has said the voucher program will be a priority when she takes office, but further expansion could face a harder path in the legislature. Last session, a bill adding 15,000 vouchers passed the House by just nine votes, and six Republican lawmakers who supported it lost their reelection bids this year. Sexton has not ruled out another expansion, but the narrow margin and the questions about how scholarships are distributed could shape the debate when lawmakers return. Under the initial law, at least 5,000 new vouchers must be added for the upcoming school year.

More from The Nashville Focal