Politics
Nashville Mayor O'Connell: Voters Must Decide How Metro Council Shrinks to 20 Seats
Mayor Freddie O'Connell says Nashville voters should have a direct say in how the Metro Council is cut from 40 to 20 members, following a Tennessee Supreme Court ruling upholding the state law. Councilmember Bob Nash says changing the Metro Charter would require a referendum, but no decision has been made on when that vote would happen.
NASHVILLE â Nashville Mayor Freddie O'Connell is calling for voters to have a direct say in how the Metro Council is reduced from 40 members to no more than 20, after the Tennessee Supreme Court upheld a state law earlier this month that mandates the downsizing.
The council is preparing to cut its size in half, ending years of legal battles between Metro Nashville and the state. But the path forward remains unclear, with city leaders grappling over how to reconcile the state mandate with the Metro Charter, which voters approved in 1962 with a 40-member council.
"We're past the point of my preference, which would be that we as Nashvillians could decide for ourselves, using the power of the Metro Charter, what the size of the metro council should be," O'Connell said. "I think our interest is in now that the state supreme court has ruled in making sure council has all the information available to follow the law."
Councilmember Bob Nash said voters could be asked to decide what the smaller council will look like, including the balance between district and at-large members. He offered examples of possible configurations, such as "a 20 member council with 17 district council members, three at large or whatever combination."
But changing the structure raises a legal question: How can Nashville comply with state law while amending a charter that currently anticipates a 40-member body?
"How do we resolve the issue with the Metro Charter, which currently anticipates a 40-member body?" O'Connell asked.
Nash said Metro's legal department believes altering the charter would require a referendum, meaning voters would have to approve any proposed changes. "We'd have to amend the charter to do this and it has to be done by referendum," Nash said.
Metro could hold a special election or wait until the next scheduled election to put the proposed changes before voters, according to Nash. Neither option has been finalized.
With no decision yet on when voters could head to the polls, it remains unclear when the Metro Council will actually shrink. The uncertainty leaves residents, council members and city departments planning for a future with a smaller legislative body but no firm timeline for how or when the transition will occur.
The 1962 charter established the 40-member council as part of Nashville's consolidated city-county government. The state law upheld by the Supreme Court this month overrides that local provision, marking a significant shift in how Nashville governs itself.
For now, O'Connell said his focus is on making sure the council has the information it needs to follow the court's ruling, even as he maintains that Nashville voters should have the final word on the structure of their local government.