Politics
Both Sides in Nashville Speedway Fight Sue Election Commission Over Petition Signatures
Supporters and opponents of a ballot measure to end auto racing at the Nashville Fairgrounds Speedway have each filed lawsuits against the Davidson County Election Commission, disputing how signatures were counted and which voter threshold applies. The dueling challenges could determine whether the measure reaches voters in summer 2027.
NASHVILLE, Tenn. â The fight over the future of the Nashville Fairgrounds Speedway has moved from the track and the petition drive into the courtroom, with both sides filing separate lawsuits against the Davidson County Election Commission over how signatures on a proposed ballot measure were counted.
The legal battle follows the commissionâs October 16 certification of a petition by the Restore Our Fairgrounds coalition, which seeks to put the question of ending auto racing at the speedway before voters in summer 2027. The petition was certified with 47,679 valid signatures.
The group Decline to Sign, which opposes the measure, filed one lawsuit in Davidson County Chancery Court alleging widespread forgery and fraud in the petition drive and arguing that the commission used the wrong threshold to determine how many signatures were required. The commission based its threshold on the number of âactiveâ registered voters in the county, which Decline to Sign says unlawfully lowered the requirement from about 47,000 signatures to 40,194.
âThis case asks a simple question: Will fraud be allowed to put a measure on the ballot to change the cityâs charter?â a spokesperson for Decline to Sign said in a statement. The group is asking the court to overturn the certification.
Decline to Sign said it submitted more than 2,000 names to the commission before certification, alleging that those people were either misled into signing or had their signatures forged. The lawsuit includes affidavits from individuals, including former Tennessee residents who have lived out of state for years, who say they want their names removed.
âThe Election Commission accepted signatures of dozens of individuals who have signed affidavits that signatures in their names were forged,â the spokesperson said. âItâs clear that multiple canvassers conducted extensive forgery and fraud, and it is also clear from the Election Commissionâs own internal recorded notes that their reviewers observed patterns of abuse.â
The group also alleges the commission improperly counted undated and duplicate entries, signatures from people who were not registered at the time they signed, and signatures that were withdrawn before the petition was filed.
Restore Our Fairgrounds, the coalition behind the petition, filed its own lawsuit arguing that the commission wrongly rejected more than 700 signatures that should have been included in the final tally. The group says those names were incorrectly labeled as ânot registeredâ when they were in fact registered voters.
The coalition, led in part by former Metro attorney Saul Solomon, is asking the court to consider its challenge only if the opposing lawsuit results in removing enough names to drop the total below the certification threshold. It also disputes the idea that the threshold is anything other than 40,194, pointing to Tennessee law on voter purging that states inactive voter registrations âshall not be included in a countyâs total of registered voters.â
âNashvillians are tired of this constant drumbeat of frivolous litigation,â said Heidi Basgall Favorite, co-founder of Restore Our Fairgrounds. âThe fact is: Decline to Sign is a thinly veiled political operation backed by Speedway Motorsports and Darden Copelandâs Calvert Street Group, which has a documented history of deceiving the public.â
Basgall Favorite also cited recent controversy over a Confederate flag displayed on a race car at the speedway this month, saying the trackâs culture âis not aligned with our community.â She called on residents to support restoring the site to community green space, with a portion used for affordable housing and cleanup of polluted Brownâs Creek.
Track officials have said the driver involved in the flag display has apologized, but the Nashville NAACP chapter has demanded accountability for how a symbol of white supremacy was allowed in a public space.
The new lawsuits mark the second legal challenge by Decline to Sign since the petition was certified. Last month, Chancellor Anne C. Martin ruled that the election commission was not required to create a process allowing voters to withdraw their names from the petition. Martin found that while the Metro Charter requires election officials to verify signatures, it does not mandate a withdrawal process, and she noted that opponents have other legal avenues to challenge the certification.
Much of the controversy surrounding the petition drive has centered on whether canvassers misled people into signing without explaining that the proposal could end racing at the fairgrounds. Hidden-camera footage previously raised questions about claims made during the signature-gathering effort.
The dueling lawsuits now put the question of whether the measure reaches the ballot in the hands of the chancery court, with both sides claiming the commissionâs count was flawed. A ruling could determine whether Nashville voters decide the speedwayâs fate next summer.