Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Nashville Focal

Nashville's independent voice

Local

Tennessee Highway Patrol to pay $70,000 to settle lawsuit from sober driver arrested for DUI

The Tennessee Highway Patrol has agreed to pay $70,000 to Stephanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, after blood work showed she was sober when a trooper arrested her for DUI. She is the second sober driver to settle with the THP, as lawsuits from others—including nine arrested by one trooper—continue to mount.

Tennessee Highway Patrol to pay $70,000 to settle lawsuit from sober driver arrested for DUI

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — The Tennessee Highway Patrol has agreed to pay $70,000 to a woman who was arrested for driving under the influence despite being sober, the second such settlement with the agency as lawsuits from wrongfully arrested drivers continue to accumulate.

The state Board of Claims approved the settlement for Stephanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, according to a spokesman for the attorney general's office. A payout is expected within the next few weeks. Blood work later confirmed Fair had not been drinking.

Fair's arrest was documented in a series of investigative reports examining sober drivers arrested for DUI. The trooper who stopped her said he detected the smell of alcohol.

"There's a very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle," the trooper said during the stop.

Fair protested her innocence. "But on my life, I don't drink alcohol," she replied. Video obtained during the investigation showed Fair eating ice cream shortly before her arrest.

She later described the encounter as frightening. "I was more scared being with that cop alone than I actually was inside the jail," Fair said.

Her attorney, Ben Raybin, said the state appears to recognize the weakness of such cases. "I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them," Raybin said.

Tennessee offers no mechanism for sober drivers to recover costs—such as legal fees or lost wages—even after DUI charges are dismissed, Raybin said. Lawsuits are the only avenue for recourse.

Fair is the second sober driver to sue the THP and reach a settlement. Thomas Manis received $75,000 after state troopers arrested him for DUI in East Tennessee.

Other drivers who shared their stories are also pursuing litigation against the state, including NASA employee Labreesha Batey and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant. Court records show Bondurant was the eighth sober driver arrested by Trooper James Zahn. A lawsuit filed this year by a Thompson Station man alleges Zahn also arrested him for DUI while he was sober, which would make him the ninth such arrest by the same trooper.

The problem extends beyond the highway patrol. Court records show the Rutherford County Sheriff's Office and La Vergne police have also settled lawsuits brought by sober drivers arrested for DUI.

The settlements highlight a pattern of questionable DUI arrests across multiple Tennessee law enforcement agencies, with drivers left to navigate a legal system that offers little recourse unless they file suit. For Fair, the $70,000 settlement closes one chapter, but the broader questions about how these arrests happen—and who is held accountable—remain unresolved.

More from The Nashville Focal