Local
Tennessee Highway Patrol to Pay $70,000 to Former Wild Orchid Singer After Sober DUI Arrest
Stephanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, will receive $70,000 from the Tennessee Highway Patrol after blood tests proved she was sober during a DUI arrest. She is the second sober driver to settle with the agency, as lawsuits from othersâincluding nine allegedly arrested by one trooperâcontinue to mount.
NASHVILLE, Tenn. â The Tennessee Highway Patrol has agreed to pay $70,000 to Stephanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, to settle a lawsuit stemming from a DUI arrest that blood work later proved was made while she was completely sober.
The state Board of Claims approved the settlement, and a payout is expected within the next few weeks, according to a spokesman for the attorney generalâs office.
Fairâs arrest was one of several highlighted in an investigative series examining sober drivers being charged with driving under the influence by state troopers. Video obtained during that reporting showed Fair eating ice cream shortly before her arrest.
The trooper who stopped her insisted he detected the smell of alcohol.
âThereâs a very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle,â the trooper said during the stop.
Fair protested her innocence at the scene. âBut on my life, I donât drink alcohol,â she replied.
She later described the fear she felt during the encounter. âI was more scared being with that cop alone than I actually was inside the jail,â Fair said.
Her attorney, Ben Raybin, said the settlement reflects the stateâs acknowledgment that many of these arrests cannot withstand legal scrutiny.
âI think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them,â Raybin said.
Tennessee offers no mechanism for sober drivers to recover the costs they incurâsuch as legal fees, towing, or lost wagesâeven after DUI charges are dismissed. Raybin said filing a lawsuit is the only avenue available to them.
Fair is the second sober driver to sue the highway patrol and reach a settlement. Thomas Manis previously received $75,000 after troopers arrested him for DUI in East Tennessee.
Court records show a growing number of similar lawsuits against the state, including multiple cases involving Trooper James Zahn, who is accused of arresting nine sober drivers for DUI. Among those suing are Labreesha Batey, a NASA employee, and Jane Bondurant, a former U.S. attorney. Bondurant was identified as the eighth sober driver arrested by Zahn; a lawsuit filed this year by a Thompson Station man would make him the ninth.
The problem extends beyond the highway patrol. The Rutherford County Sheriffâs Office and La Vergne police have also settled lawsuits brought by sober drivers who were wrongfully arrested for DUI.
The pattern raises questions about training, oversight, and accountability within Tennessee law enforcement agencies, and it leaves wrongfully arrested drivers with little recourse beyond costly litigation. For Fair, the settlement closes a chapter that began with a routine traffic stop and ended with a state payoutâone of a growing number across Tennessee.