Monday, November 16, 2026·Focal News

The Nashville Focal

Nashville's independent voice

Local

Second Charlotte Avenue Jane Doe Identified as Toni L. Gordon, 31, Nearly 40 Years After Discovery

Metro Nashville Police have identified Toni L. Gordon, 31, as the second woman found buried beneath a Charlotte Avenue rental home in the 1980s, closing another chapter in a decades-long cold case that already returned Sheila Cummings' name last year.

Second Charlotte Avenue Jane Doe Identified as Toni L. Gordon, 31, Nearly 40 Years After Discovery

Metro Nashville Police detectives have identified the second of two women found buried in shallow graves beneath a Charlotte Avenue rental home nearly four decades ago, giving a name to a victim long known only as "Charlotte Avenue 'Lil Bit' Jane Doe."

The woman was Toni L. Gordon, 31, police said. Her identification comes roughly a year after detectives identified the other victim, 23-year-old Sheila Cummings, who had also gone unnamed for decades.

The case dates to the 1980s, when the remains of two women were discovered in shallow graves under the rental property on Charlotte Avenue. For nearly 40 years, investigators worked to determine who the women were, relying on evolving forensic techniques and persistent detective work.

Gordon's family had believed she moved away, according to reporting on the case, leaving them unaware that she had been a victim of the long-unsolved burial site.

The identification of both women marks a significant milestone for the department's cold case efforts and for the families who spent years without answers. Cummings was identified last year at age 23, and Gordon's identification now completes the effort to name both victims.

Details about how Gordon was identified, including the forensic methods used, were not immediately available. Police have not announced any arrests or suspects in connection with the deaths.

The Charlotte Avenue case has long been one of Nashville's most enduring mysteries, with the victims known only by the location where they were found and, in one case, a nickname. The identification of Gordon and Cummings offers a measure of closure to relatives and demonstrates the potential of renewed investigative attention to cold cases.

Metro Nashville Police have not released additional information about the circumstances of the burials or the ongoing investigation.

More from The Nashville Focal