Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Nashville Focal

Nashville's independent voice

Local

Nashville Judge Denies Clean Record to Man Who Secretly Filmed Women During Sex

Judge Jim Todd refused judicial diversion for Matthew Vollmer, keeping four misdemeanor unlawful photography convictions on his record after seven of 12 victims testified. Vollmer avoids jail under a plea deal, but the case helped spur a change in Tennessee law making unlawful photography a felony.

Nashville Judge Denies Clean Record to Man Who Secretly Filmed Women During Sex

A Davidson County judge on Friday denied judicial diversion to a Nashville man who secretly recorded women during sex, ensuring the convictions will remain on his record after an emotional hearing in which seven of his 12 victims asked the court to hold him accountable.

Matthew Vollmer pleaded guilty in August to four misdemeanor counts of unlawful photography. He had asked Judge Jim Todd for diversion, a legal mechanism that would have allowed him to clear his record upon successful completion of probation. Instead, Todd ruled that Vollmer will carry the convictions, though he will not serve jail time under the plea agreement and will instead be placed on probation.

The decision followed hours of victim testimony. One after another, women took the stand to describe the betrayal and lasting harm caused by Vollmer's conduct.

"I stand for every woman whose trust was betrayed, whose body was recorded without consent, and whose peace was stolen," Sydney Tasker told the court through tears.

Christina Werner said the violation was difficult to articulate. "I felt violated in a way that's difficult to put into words," she testified. Another victim told the judge, "I want the magnitude of what happened to us to matter."

Vollmer's attorney argued that he had no prior criminal history and that a permanent record would damage his prospects, saying, "He's not going to get a job." The defense also contended that Vollmer had changed, telling the court, "He chose to work on himself, he chose to get help." Victims disputed that characterization, asserting that Vollmer had committed similar acts repeatedly without being caught.

Vollmer apologized before the ruling. "I truly am sorry," he said. "I am even more sorry standing here today than I was this morning after hearing more statements."

Todd said he had been inclined to grant diversion until he heard the testimony. "I had every intention of granting you a diversion," the judge told Vollmer. "But after hearing from all of these women and seeing this consistent pattern, which, frankly, does seem to be consistent with some of the things that you've described that you're doing in the Moon Report, I have concerns."

Todd, who was not re-elected and returned to the bench to finish the case, delivered the ruling as Vollmer's father and the victims wept.

Werner said the outcome brought closure to a ordeal that began roughly two years ago. "It has been about two years since this all started and I'm really glad that we have a final ending to it," she said.

The convictions remain misdemeanors, but the victims' advocacy helped change Tennessee law to make unlawful photography a felony, a shift that supporters say reflects the severity of the harm caused when someone records another person without consent.

More from The Nashville Focal