Politics
Underly Urges Lawmakers to Rethink School Report Cards, Rejects Using Surplus for Education
State Superintendent Jill Underly is calling for a legislative review of Wisconsin's school report cards and pushing back against using the state's projected $4.2 billion surplus to fund schools, as she seeks $2.75 billion in new education spending.
MADISON, Wis. â State Superintendent Jill Underly is urging lawmakers to take a fresh look at how Wisconsin's school report cards are designed, arguing that the methodology deserves scrutiny even as she defends the results against critics who say they paint too rosy a picture.
In an interview aired Sunday on WISN 12's "UPFRONT," Underly said the report cards, released last week, are largely shaped by state law and that any complaints about their accuracy should be directed at the Legislature.
"I think it deserves a conversation," Underly said. "What is it that they want it to measure?"
When pressed on criticism that the results overstate school performance, Underly responded: "Take it up with the Legislature. I mean, they're the ones that literally designed it, and so I'm happy to have that conversation and happy to help, lend our expertise."
The report cards weigh achievement levels relative to the number of economically disadvantaged students, a formula that is written into state statute. Underly's call for a review comes as she and the Department of Public Instruction are requesting $2.75 billion in new funding for the next state budget.
Underly said she does not want lawmakers to tap the state's newly projected $4.2 billion surplus to pay for that request, warning that surplus dollars are a one-time source that would leave schools facing the same funding cliff in two years.
"I don't want it to come from the surplus because the surplus is really a one-time fix," she said. "I want this to be something that we can sustain going forward because if we use surplus dollars, we're going to be having the same conversations in two years."
Instead, Underly is asking for what she describes as a revamp and modernization of the state's school funding system, which she called "incredibly antiquated." She noted that lawmakers "all ran on funding public schools" and said that promise should serve as a baseline for budget negotiations.
DPI's budget request would also end automatic funding increases for voucher schools, a move Underly said is aimed at increasing accountability for private schools that receive public dollars.
"What my proposal is really looking to do is make our voucher schools more accountable because they're receiving so much in public dollars," she said.
Asked whether she would support eventually ending the statewide voucher program, Underly said the state must confront whether it can sustain both systems.
"Eventually we have to look at whether we can fund both," she said. "Right now we're funding a lot into private vouchers, and we're not funding our public schools."
But Underly stopped short of calling for changes to Milwaukee's voucher program, which serves roughly 30,000 students. She said she agrees with governor-elect David Crowley that "you don't want to disrupt where kids are in school right now."
The interview also touched on national politics. U.S. Rep. Mark Pocan, a Democrat, said he wants to see the results of congressional investigations before supporting any impeachment effort against President Donald Trump or his Cabinet members once Democrats take control of Congress in January.
"I think what you're going to see is a lot of oversight," Pocan said, adding that committees have responsibilities including appropriations. "If there's an illegal act that happened, we're going to try to get to the bottom of it."
Pocan said House Democrats are working on a 100-hour and 100-day agenda that includes a stock trading ban and Medicare access measures. He also criticized Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, a fellow Wisconsin native, over the recent nationwide ground stop, saying he lacks confidence Duffy is telling the public the truth. Duffy has requested $50 billion in new FAA funding.
"We do have antiquated systems," Pocan said. "And I completely agree that we need to upgrade those, but if he's sitting on money he's already been given from Congress and not done that, then that's on him."
Republican Party of Wisconsin Chair Brian Schimming acknowledged a difficult election year nationally and in Wisconsin, saying "the roof came in" but that the state party's fundraising numbers remain strong. He said he has the backing of Sen. Ron Johnson and would support Johnson if he runs for a fourth term in 2028. WisPolitics reported that John Leiber, Howard Marklein, Scott Allen and Terry Dittrich are considering bids for state party chairman.
Schimming said the party would conduct a review of the November results. "We're certainly going to do the look back," he said. "We're working that out right now, but I encourage people to be honest."