Sunday, November 22, 2026·Focal News

The Milwaukee Focal

Milwaukee's independent voice

Local

Wisconsin's Data Center Surge Fuels Push to Restore State Energy Planning Powers

A data-center-driven electricity boom is reviving a decades-old debate over whether Wisconsin should let regulators map out utilities' long-term energy plans again, with ratepayer advocates and even the Public Service Commission saying the current hands-off approach leaves customers paying more.

Wisconsin's Data Center Surge Fuels Push to Restore State Energy Planning Powers

Wisconsin's electricity demand is projected to jump roughly 40% over the next five years, driven largely by new data centers, and utilities are preparing a multibillion-dollar buildout to meet it. But as the spending plans stack up, a long-simmering argument over who should guide the state's energy future has moved from regulatory arcana into the public spotlight — and the state's own utility commissioners are now among those calling for change.

The three-member Public Service Commission, which regulates the state's investor-owned utilities, can review proposed power plants one at a time. What it cannot do, under current law, is evaluate those projects as part of a comprehensive, long-range plan for meeting demand as affordably and reliably as possible.

That wasn't always the case. In the 1970s, Wisconsin lawmakers gave the commission broad authority to lead energy planning, creating what became known as the Advanced Plan: 20-year road maps that utilities had to submit, which regulators could revise in two-year cycles alongside consumer advocates and other stakeholders. The commission used that power to steer utilities toward cost-effective options, including energy efficiency and demand-reduction programs, and in 1993 it invited independent developers to bid on projects outlined in utility plans — a move that saved We Energies customers an estimated $66 million on a natural gas plant in Whitewater.

Lawmakers scrapped the system in 1998. Utilities had argued that comprehensive planning was cumbersome and contributed to a slowdown in construction, and a close call the previous summer — when nuclear plants in Wisconsin and Illinois went offline for repairs and utilities warned of possible widespread blackouts — pushed political and business leaders to rethink the approach. The replacement, described by former commission chief energy economist Randel Pilo as "regulation-lite," left most long-term planning in utilities' hands.

We Energies soon launched a $7 billion construction spree dubbed "Power the Future," the largest energy buildout in state history. Wisconsin's average electricity rates, the second-lowest in the Midwest in 1998, are now the region's second-highest as of August.

"Without a robust planning process, we don't have balance and we're left with higher bills," said Tom Content, executive director of the Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board. He argues that under the current system, "utilities present their spending plans to investors eager for the higher profits that come from their build-build-build agenda."

Former Republican Sen. Robert Cowles, who chaired the Senate energy committee at several points during his 38-year tenure and cast the lone vote against the 1998 bill, said preserving advanced planning could have curbed some rate increases by reducing demand through efficiency programs. "To the extent that we can avoid building additional capacity, it saves us money," he said.

Utilities maintain that regulators already have enough authority. "State regulatory staff, intervenors and the public thoroughly evaluate our projects, including their costs compared to alternatives, environmental impacts, and the actual need for these new generation resources," We Energies spokesperson Brendan Conway wrote in an email. "This robust review process ensures customers are protected every step of the way."

The current buildout is testing that claim. We Energies' parent company alone expects to spend nearly $47.5 billion on new infrastructure over the next five years. Among the projects awaiting commission action are two natural gas plants in Kenosha and Walworth counties, developed not by We Energies but by Invenergy, the nation's largest independent energy infrastructure developer. A provision in the same 1998 law that eliminated the Advanced Plan streamlined permitting for such independent "merchant plants," shielding their price tags from commission scrutiny. We Energies has applied to buy the facilities for roughly $2.8 billion, up from an initial $2.3 billion, to serve data center customers; Microsoft, which plans to subscribe to the Kenosha plant's power and pay for its purchase, declined to comment.

At an Oct. 15 hearing, commission Chair Summer Strand criticized what she called the state's "piecemeal, often whack-a-mole approach" to energy planning. She and her fellow commissioners said current law prevents them from weighing the Invenergy permits and the We Energies purchase as a single package, even though doing so might reveal a more cost-effective alternative. The commission approved Invenergy's permits last month; We Energies' purchase plans remain pending.

"The deficiencies in the current framework are ripe for legislative action," Strand said.

Outgoing Gov. Tony Evers proposed granting the commission comprehensive planning powers in his most recent budget, but the Republican-controlled Legislature rejected the provision. The question now passes to Gov.-elect David Crowley and a new Democratic-majority Legislature.

Wisconsin's approach sets it apart from most neighbors. Minnesota has required comprehensive utility planning since the early 1990s, Illinois adopted the practice this year, and Michigan reinstated it a decade ago. Michigan Public Service Commission chair Dan Scripps said the state needed "a better planning process" as a wave of plants faced retirement. Michigan's residential rates remain the highest in the Midwest, though supporters attribute that largely to distribution system upgrades and years of deferred maintenance rather than generation costs.

Iowa, by contrast, has the region's lowest retail electricity prices without comprehensive planning — a fact researcher Jonathan Kim of the Energy and Policy Institute attributes to the state's early adoption of wind power, which now supplies about 60% of its in-state generation, compared with about 12% in Wisconsin. Kim cautioned that planning alone is no cure-all, noting that utilities "routinely overproject demand growth or need for new projects so that the amount they have to build seems greater."

Pilo, the former commission economist, supports "modest reform" even as he recalls the Advanced Plan's flaws. He said a "major transformation" in the state's energy sector calls for a model focused on affordability, competition and "public stewardship."

Content, of the Citizens Utility Board, put it more bluntly in an October statement: "It's long overdue that we give the state the tools it lacks. Until we do, the PSC is trying to guide the state down the 'energy future highway' without a GPS, or even a map."

More from The Milwaukee Focal