Local
West Allis Man Charged with Homicide in Wife's 2024 Death After Opioids and Sleep Aid Found in Her System
Benjamin Carpenter faces first-degree intentional homicide charges in the death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, two years after the 40-year-old marathon runner collapsed at home. Prosecutors cite unexplained opioids, a high level of sleep aid, blunt force trauma to her neck, and alarming texts as evidence.
MILWAUKEE â A West Allis man made his first court appearance Wednesday on a charge of first-degree intentional homicide in the 2024 death of his wife, a case that her parents say has left them reeling after two years of unanswered questions.
Benjamin Carpenter is accused in the death of Erica Carpenter, a 40-year-old marathon runner who collapsed in her West Allis home and died. Her death certificate had listed the cause as "undetermined," a finding that her mother, Debbie Clarenbach, said never sat right with her.
"That always bothered me, because they did find pneumonia in the autopsy," Clarenbach said. "And I thought, how could a 40-year-old healthy woman die of pneumonia?"
According to charging documents, prosecutors found unexplained opioids and a high amount of sleep aid in Erica's system, along with blunt force trauma to her neck. Investigators also uncovered text messages Erica sent to her husband, including one that read, "And what the [expletive] have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?"
The revelations came as a shock to her parents, who said they had no reason to suspect anything was wrong before their daughter's death.
"It was a bombshell. We didn't expect anything like that," said Mike Clarenbach, Erica's father.
The criminal complaint also states that Carpenter admitted to being "intimate with another female" before Erica's death. That woman reportedly told Carpenter she would not date him until he divorced Erica. After Erica's passing, Carpenter began dating the woman, but a year later police arrested him for assaulting her, records show. Charging documents in that case stated the woman had "bruising and swelling to her eyes" and told an Uber driver, "if she dies it was him who did it." Carpenter pleaded guilty to misdemeanor charges in that case.
The Clarenbachs said they were unaware of the extent of the investigation until this week. They recalled that police visited them in the days after Erica's death.
"They were going to investigate. And that was the last we really heard of them," Mike Clarenbach said. Asked whether they thought Ben played a role at the time, he replied, "No, not really."
Even in the two years since Erica passed, the Clarenbachs said they remained close with Carpenter and their grandsons. "We've done more with him and the boys than we did while they were together," Mike Clarenbach said.
Now, they are seeking justice and grappling with questions they may never get answered.
"I think the only thing that I can think of to say would be, 'You have no clue what you did to us. No clue,'" Debbie Clarenbach said.
"I think I would say, 'Why? Why did you have to go in that direction?'" Mike Clarenbach said.
The Clarenbachs commended the West Allis Police Department for its persistence in investigating the case.
The case is based mainly on circumstantial evidence, according to legal analyst Craig Mastantuono, who said prosecutors can sometimes build compelling cases through such evidence.
"Prosecutors can sometimes lay out compelling cases through circumstantial evidence, build up, that entices jurors, and so it'll be the challenge of the defense to really attack that, and say don't be lured in by this," Mastantuono said.
He added that the closed domestic violence case involving Carpenter's former girlfriend could potentially be used as evidence to demonstrate a pattern of conduct, depending on the judge's decision.
Carpenter is due back in court at a later date. The charge carries a potential life sentence upon conviction.