Local
Milwaukee jury convicts Thomas Zollicoffer in August 2025 killings of three people
A Milwaukee County jury found Thomas Zollicoffer guilty on all counts Thursday for the shooting deaths of Vanessa DeHerrera, Scott Bucholz, and Shamarla "Asir" Hare in two separate incidents last August. He faces a mandatory life sentence.
MILWAUKEE â A Milwaukee County jury on Thursday convicted Thomas Zollicoffer on all counts for the shooting deaths of three people in two separate incidents last August, court records show. The verdict, reached in less than an hour of deliberation, means Zollicoffer faces a mandatory life sentence.
The case centered on two shootings that prosecutors say unfolded on the same day. According to a criminal complaint, Zollicoffer went to an apartment gathering near 21st and Pierce streets, where his ex-girlfriend, 26-year-old Vanessa DeHerrera, and her friend, 29-year-old Scott Bucholz, were spending time. Prosecutors alleged he shot and killed both.
Investigators said Zollicoffer then went to a rooming house near 39th and Townsend streets looking for his drug dealer. When the person was not there, prosecutors alleged, he shot and killed 38-year-old Shamarla "Asir" Hare.
Zollicoffer was arrested three days after the killings following a standoff at a home near 84th Street and Fiebrantz Avenue, police said.
During the trial, Zollicoffer took the stand in his own defense, claiming one of the shootings was accidental and the other two were acts of self-defense. "My actions probably caused her death, yes. Me trying to save her actually hurt her," he testified. Under questioning by a prosecutor, Zollicoffer acknowledged that he did not call 911 or ask the driver of the car he was in to call.
Earlier in the week, a witness who took the stand became emotional as she described the moment she said she saw Zollicoffer kill his ex-girlfriend. "Thomas standing over Vanessa, shooting her," the witness said through tears. "He shot her twice and then I ran."
The jury began deliberating Thursday afternoon and notified the court shortly after that it had reached a verdict. The convictions bring a close to a case that has weighed on the community since the shootings last summer. Zollicoffer is scheduled to be sentenced at a later date.