Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Milwaukee Focal

Milwaukee's independent voice

Local

Milwaukee Judge Imposes Three Consecutive Life Sentences on Thomas Zollicoffer for Triple Murder

A Milwaukee County judge sentenced Thomas Zollicoffer to three consecutive life terms without supervised release for the August murders of Vanessa DeHerrera, Scott Bucholz, and Shamarla 'Asir' Hare, calling him 'a monster' and 'a sociopath.'

Milwaukee Judge Imposes Three Consecutive Life Sentences on Thomas Zollicoffer for Triple Murder

MILWAUKEE — A Milwaukee County judge on Friday sentenced Thomas Zollicoffer to three consecutive life sentences without the possibility of supervised release for the murders of three people in the city last August, one day after a jury convicted him on all counts.

Judge David Borowski handed down the sentences for first-degree intentional homicide in the deaths of Vanessa DeHerrera, 26; Scott Bucholz, 29; and Shamarla "Asir" Hare, 38. Zollicoffer also received five years of confinement and five years of extended supervision for each of four counts of possession of a firearm by a felon.

"Some people are so evil, so sadistic, such devilish monsters that they have not one iota of redeeming qualities. Not one," Borowski said from the bench. "This defendant, and I don't want to look at him to even give him the dignity of looking at him, is a monster."

The judge said Zollicoffer smirked repeatedly during the hearing and called him a sociopath. "The need to protect the public is extreme," Borowski said. "I don't have words to describe how dangerous he is to the public."

Borowski noted that Wisconsin does not have the death penalty but said Zollicoffer would be eligible if it did. He also referenced recent sentence commutations by Gov. Tony Evers, saying governors do not listen in court and that such relief should never be granted to Zollicoffer. The judge further lamented what he described as Milwaukee's decline in public safety, saying that while some celebrate a lower homicide rate, one killing is too many.

According to a criminal complaint, Zollicoffer went to an apartment gathering near 21st and Pierce streets, where DeHerrera, his ex-girlfriend, and her friend Bucholz were spending time, and shot and killed both. He then went to a rooming house near 39th and Townsend streets looking for his drug dealer; when the person was not there, prosecutors allege, he shot and killed Hare. Zollicoffer was arrested three days later after a standoff at a home near 84th Street and Fiebrantz Avenue.

A Milwaukee County jury deliberated for just 40 minutes on Thursday before finding Zollicoffer guilty on all counts. Moments after the verdict, he got into a heated exchange with the judge, who ordered sentencing for the following day. As the family cheered, Zollicoffer told the courtroom, "They still dead."

During the trial, Zollicoffer testified in his own defense, claiming one shooting was accidental and the other two were acts of self-defense. "My actions probably caused her death, yes. Me trying to save her actually hurt her," he testified. Under questioning by a prosecutor, he acknowledged that he did not call 911 or ask the driver of the car he was in to call.

Earlier in the week, a witness who took the stand became emotional as she described seeing Zollicoffer kill his ex-girlfriend. "Thomas standing over Vanessa, shooting her," the witness said through tears. "He shot her twice and then I ran."

Family members of the victims addressed the court before sentencing. DeHerrera's family noted that Thursday, the day of the conviction, would have been her birthday. "She loved her kids more than anything in this world. And now they are forced to live without her because of this monster," said Briana Carpe, DeHerrera's cousin. "We ask that you sentence him to the max that you can give him," said Kelly Carpe, DeHerrera's aunt. Monica Pitcher, DeHerrera's mother, said, "I hate you Thomas. Do not ever say my daughter's name."

Melanie Larson, Bucholz's mother, told the court, "Every day is a new hit and blow to life without your child," and "Knowing that somebody deliberately took your child's life is a whole new level of heartbreak." She called Zollicoffer "an evil being" and "truly the devil."

Tarshia Hare, Shamarla Hare's grandmother, became emotional during her statement, saying, "I blame you, you monster!" before having her statement read to the court when she could not continue. Tiarra Green, Hare's sister, said, "I want to say to Thomas, and this may sound crazy, but I hold no hate in my heart for you." Torva Hare, Hare's mother, said, "Thomas, you are the monster under the bed that I told her did not exist."

After the verdict, Monica Pitcher said the conviction brought some solace. "She was an amazing person and a lot of forgiveness, and she met the devil. Today is her birthday. I know that she was here with us. We got justice," she said.

The sentencing closes a case that has shaken the community and renewed attention on gun violence and repeat offenders. Zollicoffer will spend the rest of his life in prison with no possibility of supervised release.

More from The Milwaukee Focal