Local
Plantation Man Charged With Sending Peanut-Butter-Smeared Card to Woman With Severe Allergy
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, is accused of mailing a greeting card laced with peanut butter to his ex-wife's best friend, who suffered hives and hours of tingling and has a life-threatening peanut allergy. He faces aggravated battery and culpable negligence charges.
A 68-year-old Plantation man has been arrested and charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence after authorities say he mailed a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to a woman with a life-threatening peanut allergy, according to an arrest report.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. was taken into custody Friday, more than a year after the August 2025 incident, and booked at the Broward Sheriff's Office after a hospital medical clearance. His bond was set at $20,000.
According to the report, the woman returned home from work and found a blue envelope in her mailbox that appeared greasy and bore handwriting she did not recognize. Inside was a greeting card containing a substance she immediately identified as peanut butter.
Police said the exposure caused hives on both arms and a tingling sensation that lasted about six hours. The report describes the woman as "deathly allergic" â someone who must be vocal about her allergy at restaurants and who does not accept food without explaining that she cannot come into contact with peanuts, peanut oil or items that have been cross-contaminated. Authorities noted she can react through touch, ingestion or airborne exposure, and that without immediate medical intervention she could die.
The woman told investigators that Cancellare, who was married to her best friend, would have known about her allergy because the couples dined together countless times and he had to be mindful of accidental peanut contact.
The report states that Cancellare's divorce from the woman's best friend was contentious and that he largely blamed the victim for the breakup. Police said his hostility was not kept private: he made it well known in their friend group that he wished her harm.
Investigators also contacted the U.S. Postal Inspector because the card was sent through the mail. Surveillance footage showed Cancellare purchasing the two stamps used on the envelope, according to the report. Police said that despite more than three years having passed, he drove to a post office in a different city from where he lived, wore sunglasses inside the business in an attempt to disguise himself, and wrote a fictitious name and return address on the envelope.
It was not immediately clear why the investigation took more than a year to conclude. Police said the woman experienced extreme distress that was still visible when she gave her statement over a year later, and that she wishes to press charges.
The case highlights the severe risks faced by people with food allergies, for whom even trace contact can trigger a medical emergency. It also underscores how mail can be used to deliver a substance intended to cause harm â a scenario postal inspectors and local police treated as a coordinated investigation.