Local
Florida Executes Thomas Overton for 1991 Tavernier Murders, Setting Modern-Era Record
Thomas Mitchell Overton, 71, was put to death Thursday for the 1991 rape and murder of a Tavernier couple, becoming Florida's 20th execution of the year â the most since the Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976. Two more executions are scheduled for December.
RAIFORD, Fla. â Florida carried out its 20th execution of the year Thursday evening, surpassing its modern-era record for a single year, when Thomas Mitchell Overton was put to death for the 1991 rape and murder of a Tavernier couple.
Overton, 71, was pronounced dead by lethal injection at Florida State Prison at 6:19 p.m., according to the state Department of Corrections. The U.S. Supreme Court denied his latest appeal Thursday afternoon, clearing the way for the execution.
The 20 executions this year exceed the 19 carried out in 2025 and mark the highest annual total since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976. Two additional warrants signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis are scheduled for Dec. 1 and Dec. 10, which would bring the governor's total to 50 over his eight years in office. The majority of those executions have occurred in the past two years.
Overton was arrested in 1997 for the August 1991 killing of Michael MacIvor, 30, and Missy MacIvor, 29, who was eight months pregnant at the time. According to court records, Overton knew the couple because he worked as a service station clerk in Tavernier, part of Key Largo, before breaking into their home.
Michael MacIvor was struck in the back of the head with a blunt object, kicked in the midsection and strangled. Missy MacIvor was bound, raped and then strangled.
A fellow inmate at the Monroe County Detention Center, James Zientek, testified that Overton said he had broken into the home to rape Susan MacIvor and killed the couple to confuse the crime scene. The sentencing order stated that evidence at the scene was consistent with Zientek's testimony and showed beyond a reasonable doubt that avoiding detection was a central part of Overton's plan.
Despite those efforts, Overton's DNA was found in separate tests conducted in 1996 and 1998, matching a bedding sample from the MacIvors' home.
Overton was sentenced to death in 1999 for the murders. He also received life sentences for sexual battery on Missy MacIvor and for burglary of a dwelling, and 15 years for the death of an unborn child.
DeSantis has defended the pace of executions, saying capital punishment is necessary to deliver justice for victims' families. "I don't know if closure is the right word, because you'll probably never get full closure. But at least knowing justice was served is something that was very important to a lot of people," the governor said during a July 28 appearance at the Florida Sheriff's Association Summer Conference at Trump National Doral.
Last year, DeSantis suggested the death penalty could be a "strong deterrent" if sentences were carried out more quickly. During the COVID-19 pandemic years of 2020-2022, he signed no death warrants. His predecessor, now-U.S. Sen. Rick Scott, signed 28 death warrants during his two terms.
Death penalty opponents are urging Gov.-elect Byron Donalds to slow the pace of executions once he takes office. Herman Lindsey, executive director of Witness to Innocence, said the goal is not to abolish capital punishment but to ensure the incoming governor understands the stakes.
"It's not about him ending the death penalty," Lindsey said. "But I want to give him the knowledge and assist him to learning anything he needs to know about the penalty so he can make the right decision."
The record-setting year comes as Florida continues to expand its use of capital punishment, a trend that has drawn scrutiny from civil liberties and human rights advocates who point to the irreversible nature of the penalty and the lengthy, costly appeals process. For the families of the MacIvors, the execution closes a case that has spanned more than three decades.