Politics
Wisconsin Democrats' Energy Agenda Takes Shape at Madison Forum
With Democrats poised to control all of state government, a Citizens Utility Board forum in Madison focused on integrated resource planning, a beefed-up Public Service Commission and energy efficiency as ways to bring down rising utility bills.
MADISON â With Wisconsin on the verge of unified Democratic control of state government and voters increasingly focused on rising utility bills, the Citizens Utility Board convened an energy affordability forum Tuesday at the Park Hotel, where residents, advocates, policymakers and experts discussed ways to bring costs down.
The results of this month's election were repeatedly cast as an opening to upend an energy status quo that participants said has favored fossil fuel plants, utility shareholder returns and the needs of tech companies building massive data centers over the finances of ordinary ratepayers.
Kristy Nieto, a member of the Wisconsin Public Service Commission, the regulatory body that oversees the state's utilities, said Wisconsin was once a national leader in regulating utilities in ways that benefited regular people and the environment. She argued the commission should be given the staffing, budget and authority to restore that role.
"We have to fundamentally rethink how we approach affordability and the tools that we have to mitigate rate increases," Nieto said. "Business as usual won't cut it, but despite the challenges that we face, I think there's something important that Wisconsin has going for it right now. We have an opportunity to lead again."
She pushed back on the argument that the commission should avoid steps it has not taken before or that other states have not adopted. "When done thoughtfully, competently and rationally, being an outlier can be a good thing," Nieto said, noting Wisconsin was an outlier when it established modern utility regulation during the Progressive era.
Nieto outlined three levers for making energy more affordable: a more holistic planning process for the state's energy portfolio, additional tools for the PSC to prioritize lowering costs when setting electric rates, and greater staff capacity to regulate an increasingly complex industry.
In the weeks since the election, lawmakers, environmental groups and affordable energy advocates have coalesced around "integrated resource planning" as a top priority when the legislative session begins in January. Under such a system, utilities would submit future plans to the PSC for approval, forecasting how much power they will need, where it will come from and how they will pay for it. The process would include public input and, supporters say, help push utilities toward building more renewable energy.
Wisconsin is one of only a few states without an integrated resource planning requirement.
Emma Heins, who works on Wisconsin policy for the clean energy trade group Advanced Energy United, said data centers are straining the state's energy system and that Wisconsin needs a way to address the broader landscape rather than handling demand issues case by case.
"Wisconsin is really, really overdue for an integrated resource plan," Heins said, adding that the approach would benefit regulators who could see the whole picture, utilities that would gain regulatory certainty, labor groups that could plan for two decades of job opportunities, and lawmakers who would have a clearer view of the decisions being made.
Speakers also argued that once a planning process is in place, the Legislature must keep pressure on utilities and ensure regulators have the tools to do their jobs.
"The Legislature, you all have the bully pulpit. You have the microphone, the voice, to get out to the media, to leverage your constituents and to apply pressure in a holistic sense to utilities and what they are requesting of commissions," said Tremaine Phillips of the energy affordability group Powerlines. "The other way is on personnel. Our commissions as well as consumer advocates are outgunned, outmanned in these proceedings."
Advocates also pointed to energy efficiency as a major source of savings. Wisconsin already runs programs that help residents make their homes more efficient, and speakers said those could simply be given bigger budgets.
"I think there's still a misconception that it's not enough, or it's so marginal that it doesn't actually help the situation," Heins said, describing how people extrapolate modest household savings from steps like swapping in LED bulbs to the entire grid. "When we know it's a lot."
According to Citizens Utility Board analyst Jeff Adams, if Wisconsin fully takes advantage of its available programs to reduce demand, the state could save up to $1.5 billion on energy costs.
"You factor in commercial and industrial and kind of multiply things to the scale of an entire grid â it can fix a lot of problems," Heins said.