Politics
Medicaid Work Rules: States Get Six-Month Reprieve, but Paperwork Nightmare Looms
The federal government has pushed back the deadline for states to impose Medicaid work requirements to June 30, 2027, but early adopters like Nebraska and Montana are already seeing thousands lose coverage due to bureaucratic hurdles, not ineligibility.
The federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has granted states an additional six months to implement new Medicaid work requirements, extending the deadline from January 1 to June 30, 2027. The reprieve, announced in a November 13 letter from CMS Deputy Administrator Daniel Brillman, comes after months of warnings from state Medicaid agencies that meeting the original deadline would be prohibitively expensive and logistically challenging.
Brillman described the extension as a "hold harmless" period, offering states another six months without penalty. However, the underlying difficulties remain formidable. States must still overhaul eligibility systems, hire additional staff to review documentation, and communicate a complex web of exceptions to enrollees.
Some states, like Montana and Nebraska, forged ahead with early implementation and have already encountered significant roadblocks. In Nebraska, which began enforcing work rules on May 1, 2026, state data shows that by August, 557 new Medicaid applicants had been denied. Of those, 466â83.7%âwere denied simply for failing to provide documentation proving compliance or an exemption. Among renewing enrollees, 533 were denied, with 490â91.9%âfalling into the same paperwork trap. In total, at least 956 people lost Medicaid coverage due to documentation issues, not because they failed to meet the work requirement itself.
"Early on, we saw the state send a letter to Medicaid recipients with a high-level overview of what would be needed, and it was really written at a 14th-grade reading level," said Jeremy Nordquist, president and CEO of the Nebraska Hospital Association. "That's really not something that's easily comprehensible or easily followed up on by Medicaid populations."
Nordquist emphasized that traditional outreach methods often miss the mark. "Typically these folks aren't watching local news as much as the general population. They're not following healthcare policy," he said. His organization has worked to create Spanish-language resources and encourage enrollees to keep their contact information current, noting that the Medicaid expansion population moves more frequently than the general public.
In Montana, Dr. Aaron Wernham, CEO of the Montana Healthcare Foundation, said the state's Medicaid system was already strained before work requirements were even introduced. "We have long wait times in the Medicaid call center, high rates of call abandonment by people trying to call in to get help and also very high ratesâamong the nation's highestâof renewal applications taking more than 45 days to process," Wernham said. "That was before all the work requirement stuff."
The federal rules require adults under 64 who are able-bodied and earn up to 138% of the federal poverty line (about $22,000 for an individual) to work, volunteer, or attend school at least 80 hours per month, or meet a minimum household income of $580 per month. But states must tailor eligibility calculations to their own minimum wage laws, many of which exceed the federal $7.25 per hour and change annually. In 31 states, minimum wages are higher than the federal floor, meaning enrollees would need to work fewer than 80 hours to meet the income threshold. In 20 states plus the District of Columbia, eligibility is met if one household member works at least 40 hours per month.
"It's just an additional administrative burden, not only on the Medicaid agencies, but also on providers who have to chime in to help," said Jennifer Evans, an attorney at Polsinelli and former Medicaid director for Colorado.
Data from KFF shows that 63% of adults on Medicaid already work 80 hours a month or attend school. Evans noted that most enrollees are low-wage earners who simply lack access to employer-sponsored insurance. "I don't think that the fact that the dollar number is less is going to have a material impact," she said. "It's the paperwork of providing proof of income twice a year that will be the actual significant and unnecessary burden."
In Washington, D.C., where the local minimum wage is $18.40 per hourânearly three times the federal rateâofficials are grappling with how to distinguish between District workers and federal workers. Melisa Byrd, senior deputy director of D.C.'s Medicaid program, wrote that of the approximately 75,000 adult enrollees without children who would be subject to work requirements, nearly a third appear compliant based on household income of at least $580 per month. "The biggest challenge will be ensuring that District residents are reporting all their income so that DHCF can accurately determine their total income and subsequently, their compliance with the work requirements," Byrd wrote.
Advocates warn that the new rules ignore the reality of how people use Medicaid. "Many people on Medicaid have little to no income, and little to no taxable income," said Jennifer Wagner, director of Medicaid eligibility and enrollment at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. "Many people turn to Medicaid in a time of crisis, such as when they've lost a job and are in between jobs, or they've had a medical crisis that's caused them to take time off of work."
Wagner also highlighted confusion around exemptions for students, caregivers, and the medically frail. In June, 25 Democratic-led states and D.C. sued the Trump administration over the work requirement, specifically challenging a provision that asked enrollees to prove they are too sick to work. In late October, a federal judge struck down that part of the rule, citing significant harm to enrollees and costs to states, but upheld a requirement that states look back at 12 months of claims data to determine medical frailty. States must also now review at least one month of an enrollee's work historyâa concept Wagner says is entirely new to Medicaid eligibility systems.
"This idea of looking back at a month instead of what your current circumstances are is not a concept in Medicaid," Wagner said. "It's not the way applications are structured. It's not the way eligibility systems are structured, and so this is a totally new thing."
With the June 2027 deadline now looming, states and providers are urging early and aggressive outreach. "We created Spanish language resources that our hospitals could use in their communities doing outreach to try to explain the requirements that were coming but also make sure to tell people to keep their information current," Nordquist said. "That's why it's so important we find ways to break down those barriers and get people's contact information updated as frequently as possible."