Local
Report: Most Wisconsin nonprofit hospitals get more in tax breaks than they give back
A new Lown Institute analysis finds 70% of Wisconsin nonprofit hospitals received more in tax exemptions than they spent on community benefits in 2023, a gap of $633 million statewide. Hospital groups dispute the methodology, saying it omits Medicare and Medicaid shortfalls.
Nearly three out of four nonprofit hospitals in Wisconsin received more in tax breaks than they provided in community benefits during fiscal year 2023, according to a national report released Tuesday by the Lown Institute, a nonprofit health policy think tank.
The report, "Hospital Fair-Share Spending 2026," found that 70% of Wisconsin nonprofit hospitals got more in total tax exemptions than they gave back in community benefits as Lown defines them. Nationwide, the figure was 52%.
ABC for Health, a Wisconsin public interest law firm that helps low- and moderate-income people navigate medical debt, reviewed the report and calculated that hospitals in the state collectively provided $633 million less in community benefits than they received in tax exemptions. The firm said that amount could eliminate medical debt for an estimated 341,815 residents.
"Wisconsin families are footing the bill for massive tax breaks given to nonprofit hospitals, yet a handful of wealthy hospital systems guard resources while patients drown in preventable medical debt," said Bobby Peterson, ABC for Health's executive director.
The report draws on hospitals' filings with the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and their nonprofit 990 reports to the Internal Revenue Service. To calculate a hospital's tax benefit, Lown adds savings from federal, state and local tax exemptions, lower interest on tax-exempt bonds, and tax-exempt charitable donations.
On the community-benefit side, Lown limits its count to what it calls direct spending on the community, excluding certain expenses. One notable omission is the Medicaid shortfall â the gap between what a hospital is paid by Medicaid and what it reports as the cost of that care.
Judith Garber, a senior policy analyst at Lown, said hospitals already use Medicaid shortfall figures to justify higher prices for other payers, to qualify for bonus payments for serving large numbers of Medicaid and uninsured patients, and to support their case for federally required drug discounts.
"Then they want to count it a fourth time as a community benefit," Garber said. "We exclude it for that reason and because it simply does not reflect direct spending on the community."
The Wisconsin Hospital Association pushed back sharply on the findings, calling the report "a misleading and incomplete picture of the contributions Wisconsin's nonprofit hospitals make to their communities." The association said Lown's methodology omits "billions of dollars in very real costs hospitals absorb while caring for Wisconsin patients, particularly those covered by Medicare and Medicaid." It noted that in 2023, hospitals in the state absorbed $1.6 billion in Medicaid reimbursement shortfalls and $3.3 billion in Medicare shortfalls.
"This is simply not a fair or accurate assessment," the association said in a statement.
Individual hospital systems also disputed the report. Aurora Health Care, which operates 18 hospital locations in eastern Wisconsin, said its community benefits totaled $1.93 billion in 2025, citing its own report. The system said Lown's methodology "does not capture the full scope of these investments and their impact." Froedtert ThedaCare said the Lown Institute "has used selective methodology and isolated data points to produce its report."
ABC for Health singled out three hospitals affiliated with large systems as examples of how the gaps are concentrated. At Froedtert West Bend Hospital, the report calculated community benefits were $80.8 million less than tax exemptions. At Aurora St. Luke's Medical Center in Milwaukee, the gap was $79 million, and at Aurora BayCare Medical Center in Green Bay, $38.7 million.
The report also identified 37 Wisconsin hospitals that provided community benefits exceeding their tax breaks. ABC for Health highlighted St. Croix Regional Medical Center and Mile Bluff Medical Center in Juneau County, each of which reported total benefits exceeding tax breaks by more than $11 million.
Dr. Vikas Saini, president of the Lown Institute, said the findings point to a need for stronger oversight. "Tax exemptions aren't a gift â they're an expectation, and regulators need to make sure all hospitals hold up their end of the bargain," he said.
The Lown Institute was founded in 1973 by cardiologist Dr. Bernard Lown and refocused in 2012 on health policy issues including the overuse and underuse of medical care and healthcare social responsibility.