Local
Madison officers in Corey Ruiz shooting identified as DA declines charges
Newly released Wisconsin DOJ records name three additional Madison officers involved in the July fatal shooting of Corey Ruiz, hours after the Dane County district attorney announced no criminal charges against the officer who fired the shots. All four officers remain on administrative leave pending an internal review.
MADISON â Newly released state investigation records identify three additional Madison police officers who tried to detain Corey Ruiz before he was fatally shot by a fellow officer at Williamson and South Baldwin streets in July, information authorities had previously withheld.
The records from the Wisconsin Department of Justice, made public after Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced Thursday that he would not file criminal charges against Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson, name Officers Kyle Dabbs, Sydney Davila and Anthony Vogel as the other officers involved in the attempted arrest. Baitinger-Peterson, who fired the shots, had already been publicly identified.
Ozanne's charging decision cleared the state agency to release its roughly 1,800-page investigation file, along with dash-camera footage and other evidence. The outside review is required under a state law governing officer-involved deaths.
According to Ozanne's announcement, officers were sent to the Marquette neighborhood on July 22 after a resident called 911 to report someone trying to break into a home. The person, identified as Ruiz, fled, and multiple officers chased him through the neighborhood, losing sight of him several times.
Officers caught up with Ruiz at the Williamson and Baldwin intersection, where Dabbs, Vogel, Davila and Baitinger-Peterson attempted to arrest him. A struggle followed, and officers reported that Ruiz produced a knife. Two officers deployed Tasers before Baitinger-Peterson fired three shots, according to the investigation file. Two shots struck Ruiz in the torso and head, and one missed.
The records offer new detail about each officer's role and background.
Dabbs, a sergeant with nearly two decades in law enforcement, told investigators he drove to the intersection, got out of his patrol car and tried to stop Ruiz, who crashed into him on the sidewalk. Dabbs said he tackled Ruiz, who resisted, prompting the other officers to help. He began his career in 2009 at the Maple Bluff Police Department, joined Madison police in 2021 and was promoted to sergeant in 2023. He is a certified instructor in firearms and tactical response, among other subjects.
Davila, who joined the Madison department in 2022 after working as a Dane County sheriff's deputy, told investigators she knew Ruiz from her time at the county jail, describing him as a frequent resident there. She said she had spoken with Ruiz the day before the shooting while on patrol and asked him to stop and chat the next time he saw her. Davila, the Central District's neighborhood resource officer, was the first to respond to the 911 call and identified Ruiz on home surveillance footage. At the intersection, she deployed her Taser at Ruiz's abdomen but was unsure whether it connected.
Vogel, who joined the department in 2018 and was assigned downtown, served as a public information officer and mental health liaison. He told investigators he heard officers yell "Taser" and "knife" during the struggle, then deployed his Taser, which struck Ruiz's side and back. He said he heard gunshots within "milliseconds."
Baitinger-Peterson, a department veteran of more than a decade, said he was at the end of his shift when he heard radio traffic about Ruiz and received overtime approval to respond. He told investigators he saw Dabbs tackle Ruiz, then ran to help restrain him. Baitinger-Peterson said he saw Ruiz holding a knife, called out "knife" and feared Ruiz would stab the other officers. After another officer's Taser appeared ineffective, he drew his Glock, believing deadly force was his only option, and fired twice before firing a third time when Ruiz's posture did not change.
All four officers remain on administrative leave pending an internal review into whether they violated department policies, according to police spokesperson Stephanie Fryer. Chief John Patterson said Thursday that the review likely will not be finished until next year and will be conducted by an expert from outside the department.
"While I respect the district attorney's role in our community and the independent process that led to this decision, this does not mean that the objective review of this incident is done," Patterson said.
The records do not address whether any of the officers had prior disciplinary history.
Ruiz's family said at his funeral in August that he struggled with mental health, substance use and incarceration. Protesters gathered at the intersection Thursday night after Ozanne's announcement.
The release of the records comes as the department faces continued scrutiny over the shooting and as community members press for accountability. The internal review will determine whether the officers followed department policy, a decision that could carry disciplinary consequences even without criminal charges.