Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Madison Focal

Madison's independent voice

Local

Fitchburg Quarry Redevelopment Clears Plan Commission With Noise Limits, Heads to Council

Fitchburg's Plan Commission approved a rezone for a major retail and housing project at the old Jamestown Quarry, adding 18 conditions to address neighbors' delivery-noise concerns. The proposal, which could bring Marshalls, HomeGoods, Ross and an unnamed grocery store, now goes to the Common Council.

Fitchburg Quarry Redevelopment Clears Plan Commission With Noise Limits, Heads to Council

FITCHBURG, Wis. — A long-planned redevelopment of the old Jamestown Quarry along McKee Road took a key step forward this week when the city's Plan Commission approved a rezone with conditions, sending the proposal to the Fitchburg Common Council for a final decision expected Tuesday.

The project envisions a new shopping center on the quarry site, with Marshalls, HomeGoods and Ross Dress for Less among the possible tenants, along with a specialty grocery store that has not been publicly identified. City and business officials declined to confirm the grocer.

Brandon Rounds, director of partnerships and events for the Fitchburg Chamber Visitor and Business Bureau, said the grocery tenant has not been confirmed. Deputy City Administrator Adam Sayre said the city does not comment on tenants and referred questions to the developer, adding that he expects an announcement at some point.

The surrounding area is already changing. One apartment building on the site is leased, a second is under construction, and a Chick-fil-A, a McDonald's and a Crew Carwash have recently opened nearby. The developer said construction on the shopping center could begin in May, with stores opening in February 2028.

The commission's approval came with 18 conditions on the rezone and nine conditions on a certified survey map that combines two lots into one. The conditions respond directly to concerns raised by residents of the Jamestown Quarry multifamily developments just north of the site.

In an email read at the meeting, a property owner of those apartments said he supports the project if delivery hours are limited and a permanent fence and landscaping are installed as a buffer. The email noted that about 100 residents on the south side of his building would be affected by noise from loading gates and backing delivery trucks outside normal hours.

Under the conditions, deliveries, maintenance and garbage pickup must occur between 7 a.m. and 7 p.m. Staff removed language that would have allowed the specialty grocer to begin deliveries at 6 a.m. A retaining wall, permanent fence and landscaping will separate the commercial development from the residential buildings; a member of the project team said the current plan shows a wall 14 feet tall.

Rounds said the site's history is part of what makes the project appealing. "We're standing on what used to be an old quarry, and what do you do with an old quarry but redevelop it?" he said.

Rounds, who has worked with the chamber for eight years, said the city's changes during that time have been positive and that Fitchburg is focused on attracting residents and choosing projects that fit current and future needs.

Sayre said growth brings more people, more places to shop and work, and more housing options. He said the Jamestown retail would draw shoppers from Fitchburg and beyond, putting stores closer to the city's roughly 37,000 residents.

"It's a shorter drive. Instead of driving to Middleton or into Madison, you can hopefully drive 5, 10 minutes," Sayre said.

He added that retailers want high-traffic routes and that the McKee Road location, with a Target across the street, suits larger stores. The city, he said, is encouraging small businesses in other parts of Fitchburg.

Growth is underway on the city's east, west and north sides. A new east-side community called Syncopation broke ground Monday and is slated to include townhomes, a senior facility, an amphitheater, an apartment complex and retail space. Bowman Plaza on the north side, off Fish Hatchery Road, is expected to break ground Friday with apartments and 10,000 square feet of retail; Sayre said it will be one of the tallest projects in the city.

The Common Council is scheduled to take up the Jamestown Quarry rezone on Tuesday.

More from The Madison Focal