Local
Dane County judge blocks 'rescue defense' in Ridglan Farms break-in trial
A Dane County judge ruled that four animal rights activists charged with burglary for taking 22 dogs from Ridglan Farms cannot argue their actions were legally justified as a rescue. The activists face trial in January 2027, while the controversial beagle breeding facility has since closed.
MADISON, Wis. â A Dane County judge has barred four animal rights activists from presenting a legal justification defense at their upcoming burglary trial for breaking into a controversial beagle breeding facility earlier this year and removing 22 dogs.
Judge John Hyland denied the motion, which would have allowed the defendants to introduce evidence of animal cruelty at Ridglan Farms to argue they were acting to rescue the dogs rather than committing burglary. Wayne Hsiung, Aditya Aswani, Misha Lunsky, and Dean Wyrzykowski each face felony burglary charges stemming from the March break-in at the Town of Blue Mounds facility.
"The defendantsâ motivations are inseparable from their actions," said Chris Carraway, an attorney representing Aswani. "Todayâs ruling means the jury will get only part of the story."
The activists are scheduled to stand trial in January 2027.
Ridglan Farms had been the subject of years of animal cruelty allegations, primarily concerning the treatment and living conditions of the dogs in its care. Earlier this year, the facility surrendered its breeding license to avoid criminal charges following an investigation by a special prosecutor. The facility has since closed, and its remaining dogs were sold or donated to rescue groups and shelters.
The ruling means jurors will not hear arguments that the activists' actions were legally justified by the conditions at the facility. The case has drawn attention to the tension between property law and animal welfare advocacy, with supporters of the activists arguing that the legal system should allow juries to consider the context of alleged animal suffering.
Prosecutors had previously moved to drop some charges against the four individuals, though the burglary counts remain. The trial is set to proceed in Dane County court.