Local
Dane County Judge and Pastor Everett Mitchell Receives 'Graphic' Threat Targeting His Church
Dane County Circuit Court Judge and Christ the Solid Rock Baptist Church pastor Everett Mitchell received threatening messages hoping his church would 'burn to pieces,' prompting a police presence at Sunday service and renewed calls for judicial security funding.
MADISON, Wis. â A Dane County judge who also serves as senior pastor of a local Baptist church received what he described as "graphic" and "deeply personal" threats last week, prompting a police presence at Sunday worship and drawing new attention to the growing safety risks facing Wisconsin's judiciary.
Judge Everett Mitchell, who presides on the Dane County Circuit Court and leads Christ the Solid Rock Baptist Church, announced on Facebook that the threatening messages arrived the day before Sunday service. The sender, Mitchell said, expressed hope that the church would "burn to pieces." Mitchell indicated the person who sent the threats had previously appeared before him in a court case.
"I have never faced anything like this in my years on the bench or in the pulpit," Mitchell wrote. "I will not let my work put any of you at risk. I am safe, and I love you."
When congregants arrived for Sunday service, they found officers from the Madison Police Department stationed at the church. Reverend Alfred George addressed the congregation before worship began, explaining the officers were there simply to be with them.
Mitchell reported the threats to law enforcement, who advised him to stay away from Sunday's service so his presence would not draw danger to worshipers. He asked his congregation for prayers for his family and for the person who sent the threat, writing that "they are clearly carrying deep pain."
The incident comes as Wisconsin Supreme Court Chief Justice Jill Karofsky has made courthouse and judicial security her top budget priority. In her State of the Judiciary address, Karofsky said threats against judges have not abated. "Last year I stood here and I told you that the state of our judiciary was troubled. I won't pretend that the threats have gone away. They have not," she said.
Karofsky is seeking roughly $3 million over the 2027-29 biennium to permanently fund four statewide officers in the Wisconsin Court Protection Unit, create a Court Security Improvement grant program for counties, and expand the Marshal's Office from one full-time and one part-time position to three full-time positions. In 2025, Republicans rejected a similar request for court security funding.
That same year, Wisconsin judges reported 129 threats, part of what researchers describe as a nationwide rise in threats against local elected officials. Last month, Madison Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway announced she would not seek a third term, citing threats and harassment and saying the price of holding public office had become "too high."
For Mitchell's congregation, the weekend brought a visible reminder of the tensions that can follow judges home from the bench. The pastor's message to his church was one of reassurance and compassion â even for the person who threatened them.