Politics
Floyd County Commissioner Candidate Sues for Special Election After 570 Early Voters Got Ballots Missing Her Race
Ellen Morrison Kelley, who lost the District 1 commissioner race by 153 votes, is asking a judge to order a special election in four precincts where early voters received ballots that omitted the commissioner contest. Her petition claims as many as 300 voters never cast a corrected ballot.
A Floyd County commissioner candidate is taking her election challenge to court after roughly 570 early voters in four precincts received ballots that did not include the District 1 commissioner's race, an omission she says may have cost her the seat.
Ellen Morrison Kelley lost the District 1 commissioner's race to Al Knable by 153 votes. She is asking a judge to order a special election in the affected precincts â Franklin, Greenville, Georgetown and Lafayette â where the flawed ballots were cast between Oct. 6 and Oct. 8.
"Everybody deserves the chance to vote. Everybody deserves to have a correct ballot," Morrison Kelley said. "We are going to court. We are going to ask the judge to fix it."
The Floyd County election board says the voting machine programming and ballot styles that caused the omission have since been corrected and proofed. Officials say each affected voter was sent a written explanation and given an opportunity to cast a corrected ballot that included the commissioner's race.
But Morrison Kelley argues that returning to vote a second time was not a realistic option for many residents. Her election contest petition states that as many as 300 identified voters did not cast a corrected ballot.
"They have work and children and responsible parties, and they probably voted the first day and were really proud and excited that they got the voting done," she said. "And then the day they got a letter that said, 'Oh, no, you have to do it again.'"
The margin of 153 votes is smaller than the number of voters who may have been disenfranchised by the ballot error, making the outcome of the race dependent on how the court resolves the challenge. Commissioner Knable did not respond to a request for comment.
The case raises questions about ballot accuracy and voter access in Floyd County, and it highlights the burden that correction notices can place on working families when election officials make programming errors. A court decision on the special election request is pending.