Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Louisville Focal

Louisville's independent voice

Local

Kentucky Foster Family Says Baby Deported to Guatemala Is Now in State Custody, Asks Who Will Advocate for Her

A Louisville foster family says a baby born in Kentucky and later deported to Guatemala with her biological mother has been taken into Guatemalan custody, leaving them unsure where she is and which country has authority over her future. Kentucky's attorney general and the Kentucky Press Association are now asking a court to unseal the confidential case record.

Kentucky Foster Family Says Baby Deported to Guatemala Is Now in State Custody, Asks Who Will Advocate for Her

LOUISVILLE, Ky. — A child born in Kentucky and later deported to Guatemala is now in the custody of Guatemalan authorities, according to the Louisville foster family that cared for her during her first year of life.

The case, which has moved through Kentucky family court, federal immigration enforcement and now international custody questions, has left the foster father asking who has the legal authority to act in the child's best interest.

Baby "T" was brought to Norton Women's and Children's Hospital on Aug. 2, 2025, hours after her birth, by her biological mother, Marlena, who had recently arrived in Kentucky from Guatemala. According to a police report, the infant had cuts across her body. The report states the mother told nurses she had tried to kill the baby because she did not want her. Her attorneys later challenged that account in court.

The mother was initially charged with criminal abuse, and a grand jury indicted her on attempted murder and assault charges. In July, she pleaded guilty to an amended charge of wanton endangerment and was sentenced to 340 days, with credit for time served.

Foster parent Caleb Yeske was ordered to turn the baby over to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement by Monday, Sept. 7, so she could be transferred to her birth mother's care. The baby had not been with her mother since the hours after her birth. The reunification took place over the objection of the Kentucky Cabinet for Health and Family Services, and Yeske said there is no record of a hearing finding the mother was prepared to care for the child successfully — a step he described as typical in foster cases.

Yeske said he stayed in contact with the birth mother over the past year, sharing information about the baby's medical history, preferences and daily life. In recent weeks, he said, those conversations shifted from information-sharing to a request.

"We basically just told her, 'Look, we cared for your child for the last year and some change. We want her to be set up for success. We want you to be set up for success,'" Yeske said. "We told her that we love this child and want the best for her. What can we do to support you? Do you want me to come down and visit? What does that look like? And basically, she said, 'If you come down here and help me get a passport for my daughter, you can bring her back to the United States.'"

Yeske showed notarized documents signed by Marlena allowing him to take over guardianship and travel with the baby back to the U.S. But while they were waiting for the passport from the embassy, Yeske said, Guatemalan authorities took the child into custody. He said the baby was reported missing, though it remains unclear who made the report.

The foster family said they do not know where the child is now. Even with the notarized custody papers, Yeske is still trying to determine who can rule on where she should live.

"It's very difficult to understand how a U.S. citizen is returned to another country when the cabinet, foster care here in Kentucky, agreed that reunification, at least at that time, should not occur," Yeske said. "And then, less than two months later, to be getting calls saying, 'Please, if you come and get this baby, you can bring her back to the U.S.'"

Yeske said he has been working with members of Congress and the embassy. Kentucky courts found he had no right to intervene in the mother and baby's reunification.

"Because she is not in the U.S., the argument is that trying to figure out really who has jurisdiction to rule over where the child should remain, whether that be Guatemala or the United States," Yeske said. "So, that's kind of the position that we're left in right now, is who should be advocating for this child? Who has the authority to make decisions for the best interest of this baby?"

As a foster parent, Yeske said this is a situation he never expected to be in, but he is doing what he can to make sure the child is safe.

"What I can tell you, as well as anybody who's a parent knows, is that when you love a child, that love never ends," Yeske said. "And that care and that expectation to protect and find justice and support that child is unwavering. And ultimately, that's the place that I come from as I try to advocate this baby."

The case has had a complex history in court. The foster family attempted to intervene with an emergency motion to the Kentucky Court of Appeals, but the effort was rejected. According to court records, the court found they had not met the burden to prove irreparable harm, the reunification had already been ordered and the foster parents had never had custodial rights to begin with. Their emergency motion for a stay on reunification was also rejected on similar grounds.

The foster parents additionally filed a writ challenging the reunification proceedings. They eventually withdrew it after CHFS, the birth mother's attorney and the Jefferson County Attorney's Office submitted responses arguing they had no right to make such a challenge.

Now, Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman and the Kentucky Press Association have filed motions asking the court to unseal the confidential court record. Both argue that releasing information is in the public interest, given the media attention the case has received.

KPA specifically cites a court order barring the foster parents from speaking publicly about the case, which threatened jail time if they did so. That argument speaks to the AG's motion, which cites allegations the foster parents were spreading misinformation.

The AG added that there are several questions the public deserves to have answered, laying them out in the motion, including:

- "Why was this case treated as a dependency case, Order at 4 (Sept. 9, 2026), rather than as an abuse or neglect case, given that the mother ultimately pleaded guilty to wantonly endangering the child? - What was the factual and legal basis for the Jefferson Family Court to order immediate reunification of the child with the mother without any reunification process or plan, given the requirements in Kentucky law? - What role did the mother's committing a crime against the child play in the Jefferson Family Court's reunification decision?"

The birth mother's attorney and the Jefferson County Attorney's Office have both filed responses objecting to the state's motion to unseal the record.

The case raises broader questions about how Kentucky's child welfare and immigration systems intersect — and about what happens when a U.S.-born child is removed to another country before custody questions are fully resolved. For now, the foster family says it is waiting for clarity from courts and diplomats, while insisting that the child's safety remain the central concern.

More from The Louisville Focal