Local
Bellarmine Asks Judge to Open Minority Scholarships to All Students, Citing Federal Law
Bellarmine University wants a judge to let it broaden eligibility for four donor-funded scholarships reserved for Black and minority students, arguing recent civil rights enforcement changes require it. The Louisville Urban League, whose former president is honored by one scholarship, is weighing whether to intervene.
Bellarmine University is asking a Jefferson County judge to let it widen who can receive four privately funded scholarships that were established for Black and minority students, arguing that shifting interpretations of federal and state civil rights law leave the university exposed.
The motion, filed in January with Judge Ann Bailey Smith, seeks approval to revise the scholarships' eligibility criteria. Two of the awards were restricted to Black students, a third gave preference to a Black student, and the fourth was intended for racial minorities, according to a filing by the Kentucky Attorney General's office, which backs the request.
Because the donors have died, Bellarmine says it needs court approval to alter the terms of the gifts. The university said it wrote to the donors' families before going to the judge, describing the original intentions as "noble and benevolent" and arguing that broadening eligibility would keep faith with those wishes while bringing the scholarships in line with civil rights law.
Bellarmine points chiefly to the U.S. Supreme Court's 2023 decision striking down race-conscious admissions at Harvard and the University of North Carolina. The university frames the scholarships as a compliance question rather than an admissions one.
That distinction is contested. "This is not an admissions issue," said Lyndon Pryor, president of the Louisville Urban League. "You're not trying to comply with the law because the law doesn't have anything for you to comply with as it relates to scholarships."
Pryor filed a friend-of-the-court brief opposing similar changes in a separate dispute between the University of Louisville Foundation and Attorney General Russell Coleman over a scholarship for Black medical students, a case now on appeal. He said the Urban League is reviewing whether to intervene in the Bellarmine matter as well. "It's certainly something that we are looking into and we will pursue vigorously to the best of our abilities," he said.
One of the four Bellarmine scholarships bears the name of Art Walters, a former president of the Louisville Urban League. Pryor said he knows Walters' family and is convinced the proposed changes would run counter to the donor's intent. "Knowing his family and his grandchildren and his nephews, I feel very clear in the sense that is not what his wishes would be," he said.
Judge Smith has ordered Bellarmine to contact the donors' families again and ask whether they want to take part in the case. The university reported that two of the four people contacted have responded, but its filing does not disclose whether they support the changes. The judge has requested additional information before deciding whether the university may rewrite the scholarship requirements.
The outcome matters beyond Bellarmine's campus. Kentucky has seen a widening fight over whether donor-directed scholarships for Black students can survive the post-2023 legal landscape, with the attorney general's office pressing the issue in court and civil rights groups pushing back. For Louisville families, the stakes are concrete: whether awards created to widen access for Black students will continue to do so, or be opened to a broader pool.