Local
New York City Unveils Ambitious Plan to Shut Rikers Island, Drawing on German Prison Model
Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration released a detailed road map Friday to close the violence-plagued Rikers Island jail complex and replace it with four smaller borough-based facilities, aiming to reduce the jail population by 2,000 and invest over $250 million in alternatives to incarceration.
NEW YORK â New York City officials on Friday released a long-awaited plan to close the Rikers Island jail complex, a sprawling pre-trial detention center that has become synonymous with violence and neglect, and to replace it with four smaller jails in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx.
The plan, unveiled by Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration, seeks to transform not only the buildings but the city's entire approach to public safety, officials said. It combines the construction of more humane facilities with a major push to reduce the number of people behind bars through expanded diversion programs, supportive housing and mental health treatment.
"It is long past time to close what's been a moral stain on our city," Mamdani said. "We cannot simply accept the old approaches to public safety just because they've always been done that way."
Rikers, situated on a former garbage dump in the East River, has faced decades of lawsuits and federal oversight over conditions that a federal judge last year called an "unconstitutional danger" to both detainees and staff. Since 2022, more than 50 people have died in the custody of the Department of Correction, nearly all of them at Rikers. A federal judge stripped the city of its authority over the jail last year, appointing a remediation manager to bring the system into legal compliance.
The new plan, which officials acknowledge will miss the original 2027 closure deadline set by the City Council in 2019, projects that the four borough-based jails will be fully completed in about six years. Together they will hold roughly 2,000 fewer people than the approximately 6,600 currently at Rikers. The city is committing more than $250 million over the next several years to reduce the jail population, including through alternatives to incarceration such as electronic monitoring and diversion programs.
A key inspiration for the plan is the German prison system, which a growing number of U.S. correctional leaders have looked to as a model. Nicholas Deml, the remediation manager, and Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards traveled to Germany earlier this year on a trip organized by the Vera Institute of Justice. In his compliance plan, Deml wrote that German systems "reflect a fundamentally different orientation â one that places human dignity at the center of incarceration."
Last month, the Vera Institute led a second delegation to Germany that included a prosecutor, a judge, a city councilmember and the chief who supervises officers at Rikers. At Berlin's Moabit jail, they observed quiet hallways, cells with windows to the outside, televisions to calm detainees and even a cigarette vending machine in the corridor.
"I'll never forget the cigarette vending machine," said Christopher Watler, the newly appointed chair of the New York City Board of Correction. What struck him, he said, was what the gesture communicated about treating people as human. "New York City's a great city. Our jail system isn't great," Watler said. "It's a broken thing. But how do you repair broken things?"
Just a week before his trip, Watler presided over his first board meeting in New York, where he heard anonymous phone calls from people held at Rikers describing black mold, denied medications and pleas for a less violent environment.
Officials cautioned that new buildings alone will not solve the systemic problems. A federal report has documented a "culture of violence" among guards, and in 2023 more than 700 women sued the city alleging they were raped or sexually abused by staff at Rikers. The city's plan outlines more training and mentoring for staff, tighter oversight and expanded programming for detainees.
Commissioner Richards, the first formerly incarcerated person to lead the department, said he wants to see the culture transform to mirror what he observed in Germany, where dignity is non-negotiable for everyone, including staff who he said have been demonized.
"Part of the work that I'm doing is showing value and appreciation to our staff. So they begin to expand their capacity to show that same value and humanity to the people who come to us," Richards said. But he offered few specifics, noting that his immediate focus is safety and security, starting with basic protocols such as securing doors. "Everybody wants something to happen by tomorrow. And we are in a moment of urgency. But it takes time to turn," he said.
A major challenge is reducing the jail population enough to fit into the new facilities. The average length of stay in city custody was nearly twice as long in 2025 as in 2015, according to the policy journal Vital City. Nearly a quarter of people at Rikers have been held for more than a year, most awaiting trial. The city plans a task force to speed up court cases, but judges and district attorneys operate independently of City Hall.
"The only way to solve this backlog problem is to hit each of these things. The sum of all of the efforts will help," said Judge Joseph Zayas, chief administrative judge of the New York State Unified Court System.
Some former officials worry about what happens if the population doesn't shrink enough. Vincent Schiraldi, who was correction commissioner under Mayor Bill de Blasio, said forecasting lower incarceration numbers takes courage. "If you are wrong, then you have crowded jails and you're in trouble," he said. But he pointed to New Orleans, which reduced its jail population by more than two-thirds in the decade after Hurricane Katrina, and noted that crime rates have trended downward for decades.
Elizabeth Glazer, who led the Office of Criminal Justice under de Blasio, said she hopes the mayor will be pragmatic about contingency plans, including the possibility of building again on Rikers. "It requires relentless attention, coordination and organization around a common goal to get it done," she said. "Even if you hit that number, the question is, can that be sustained for the decades when all you have is that capacity?"
For advocates, the plan represents a crucial opportunity after years of inaction. "We wait for these perfect plans, and for all the reasons we know, including funding, those perfect plans never come to pass. And so what do we do? We do nothing," said Tina Luongo, who leads the criminal defense practice at the Legal Aid Society, which brought the class action lawsuit that led to the remediation manager's appointment.
Insha Rahman, president of the Vera Institute of Justice, said the plan's ambition could have national ripple effects. "If New York City can do this at scale, which it will, it is encouragement for places like LA, like Chicago, like Philadelphia, like Houston to do the same," she said.
The larger goal, officials said, is to ensure that the failures of Rikers are not carried into the next generation of city jails.