Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Las Vegas Focal

Las Vegas's independent voice

Politics

Judge's ruling in Coyote Springs water case could cost Nevada over $1 billion, reshape water law

A Clark County judge ruled that the state's refusal to extend water rights for the planned Coyote Springs development was an unconstitutional taking, potentially costing taxpayers over $1 billion and throwing Western water law into chaos.

Judge's ruling in Coyote Springs water case could cost Nevada over $1 billion, reshape water law

A Clark County District Court ruling has upended Nevada water law, with a judge finding that the state's management of groundwater rights for a long-planned development northeast of Las Vegas amounted to an unconstitutional taking of private property. The decision, issued Wednesday by Judge Mark Denton just before his retirement, could force state taxpayers to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to the developers and has sparked warnings of a crisis in how water rights are administered.

The case centers on Coyote Springs, a proposed city that would have been twice the size of Summerlin, with up to 160,000 homes, golf courses, and hotel-casinos. The developers, California businessmen Albert and Thomas Seeno, argued that the state engineer's determinations effectively rendered their water permits useless, blocking the project. Denton agreed, ruling that the state's approach to managing the groundwater basin was a taking. A jury will now decide damages; the developers are seeking $600 million, but with interest and attorneys' fees, the total could exceed $1 billion, according to Laura FitzSimmons, an attorney for the state.

"This decision is unfathomable," FitzSimmons said. "No court in any state or anywhere in this country has ever found that a water permit is a property right that requires compensation." She called the ruling "a catastrophe for Nevada." The state has not yet decided whether to seek immediate relief from the Nevada Supreme Court or wait until the damages phase concludes.

The ruling has sent shockwaves through the water law community. Debbie Leonard, a Northern Nevada water attorney not involved in the case, said the decision "throws everything I've known and understood about Western water law into total chaos." She warned that the state engineer may now be reluctant to grant new water permits or extensions of time, fearing that any denial could be construed as a taking. "I don't think it's hyperbole to say that this is going to plunge the state into crisis over economic development and water resources," Leonard said. "Now, the state engineer is not going to want to grant a single application."

Tom Romero, a UNLV law professor, agreed that the ruling puts the state's ability to administer water rights in flux. He noted that the Nevada Supreme Court in 2024 upheld the state engineer's decision to merge several connected water basins into a "superbasin," but the trial court's opinion now suggests that managing the region under that regime could itself be a taking. "This, however, would make moot all of the power affirmed in the (Nevada Supreme Court) case," Romero wrote in an email.

Attorneys for the developers and property rights advocates see the ruling differently. Mark Hutchison, who represented the Seenos and served as Nevada's Republican lieutenant governor from 2015 to 2019, said the developers had exhausted legal remedies and were owed compensation. "My message to taxpayers is that this is the way that the United States Constitution is structured to hold government accountable," Hutchison said. He added that his clients have no plans to revive the original city proposal; instead, the land may host a massive solar project.

In mid-October, Nevada energy regulators granted conditional approval for an 8,177-acre, 1,200-megawatt solar installation proposed by Reno-based Estuary Power. If built, it could become one of the nation's largest solar projects. NV Energy has signed a power-purchase agreement for 600 megawatts from the first phase, pending state approval, and Lincoln County commissioners unanimously approved the development in early October. However, the project still needs additional permits, including from the Federal Aviation Administration for its second half.

Environmentalists are raising concerns about the solar project's location. Patrick Donnelly, Great Basin director for the Center for Biological Diversity, said the land is intact habitat for the Mojave desert tortoise, a threatened species. "These are all essential desert tortoise habitat in a climate change scenario," Donnelly said, noting that the animals are expected to seek refuge in cooler areas of Nevada as Southern California warms.

Damien Schiff, an attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation, called the ruling a rare win for property rights but downplayed its broader impact. "To anyone who's concerned about some threat to the ability of government to regulate water consumption, especially in arid states like Nevada, I would say that concern would be misplaced," Schiff said. He argued the decision should inform future regulation rather than be seen as a radical bellwether.

With Denton's retirement, a new judge will oversee the damages phase of the trial. The outcome could have lasting implications for how Nevada manages its scarce water resources and for developers across the West.

More from The Las Vegas Focal