Local
Tennessee Highway Patrol to pay $70,000 to former Wild Orchid singer arrested for DUI while sober
Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, will receive $70,000 from the Tennessee Highway Patrol after blood tests proved she was sober during a 2024 DUI arrest. The settlement highlights a growing pattern of lawsuits from sober drivers wrongly arrested by state troopers.
NASHVILLE, Tenn. â The Tennessee Highway Patrol has agreed to pay $70,000 to Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, to settle a lawsuit over her wrongful DUI arrest, according to the state attorney general's office.
The state Board of Claims approved the settlement, and payment is expected within the next few weeks. Blood work later confirmed that Fair had not been drinking at the time of her 2024 arrest.
Fair was pulled over by Trooper Keith Velez, who claimed he detected "a very distinct odor of alcohol" coming from either Fair or inside her vehicle. Fair protested, telling the trooper, "But on my life, I don't drink alcohol." Video obtained during the investigation showed Fair eating ice cream shortly before the stop.
"I was more scared being with that cop alone than I actually was inside the jail," Fair said of the encounter.
Her attorney, Ben Raybin, said the state has come to recognize the legal vulnerability of such arrests. "I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them," Raybin said.
Tennessee currently offers no recourse for sober drivers to recover costsâsuch as towing fees, legal bills, or lost wagesâeven after DUI charges are dismissed. Raybin noted that filing a lawsuit is the only option available to clear one's name and seek compensation.
Fair is the second sober driver to settle with the highway patrol. Thomas Manis received $75,000 after troopers arrested him for DUI in East Tennessee. Several other sober drivers have pending lawsuits, including NASA employee Labreesha Batey and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant.
Court records reveal a troubling pattern: one trooper, James Zahn, has been accused of arresting at least nine sober drivers for DUI, including Bondurant. A lawsuit filed this year by a Thompson Station man alleges Zahn arrested him while he was sober, which would make him the ninth such case tied to the trooper.
The problem extends beyond the highway patrol. The Rutherford County Sheriff's Office and La Vergne police have also settled lawsuits from sober drivers arrested for DUI, according to court records.
The settlement underscores concerns about DUI enforcement practices and the lack of a clear path to justice for drivers who are wrongly arrested. For Fair, the payout brings a measure of accountability, but the broader pattern of sober DUI arrests continues to raise questions about training and oversight within Tennessee law enforcement agencies.