Local
St. Augustine Brewery Owner Sues City Over Nights of Lights Parking Expansion
Andrew Horn, owner of Hornski's Brewery, has filed a lawsuit against St. Augustine, alleging the city violated state law when it expanded parking restrictions and tripled fines to $100 ahead of the busy Nights of Lights season. The suit claims the city's required business-impact survey listed 'NONE' and was filed late.
ST. AUGUSTINE, Fla. â A St. Augustine business owner has sued the city over its plan to expand parking restrictions and sharply increase fines during the lucrative Nights of Lights holiday season, alleging officials cut corners on the state-required review process and shut out local businesses.
Andrew Horn, owner of Hornski's Brewery on Anastasia Boulevard, filed the lawsuit challenging the city's approval of expanded parking rules affecting commercial districts along the corridor and extending into the North and Davis Shores neighborhoods. Under the new regulations, local parking fines will triple to $100.
At the center of the complaint is the city's handling of a required business-impact analysis. According to the court filing, Florida law requires local governments to complete a neighborhood survey before enacting non-exempt ordinances. Instead of providing a numerical count of the commercial establishments affected by the expanded rules, city officials filled in the documentation with a single word: "NONE."
Marcus Thompson, managing attorney at Trinity Law & Title, which represents Hornski's Brewery, said the city also missed deadlines. The business impact form was not submitted until two days after the ordinance had already passed the first of its two mandatory readings before the city commission.
Thompson criticized municipal leaders for failing to consult with business owners before advancing the parking changes.
"They should have come to the business owners like last February and talked about this and actually had a dialog and put a plan in place," Thompson said. "Instead, they tried to slip it in under everybody's noses."
Horn said the restrictions put multiple commercial operations in jeopardy, warning that businesses lining Anastasia Boulevard could face closure if their guests have nowhere to park. The lawsuit contends the city failed to comply with state statutory requirements governing municipal ordinances.
The dispute comes as St. Augustine prepares for Nights of Lights, the winter light display that draws hundreds of thousands of visitors to the historic city and is a major economic driver for local shops, restaurants and hotels. Business owners along Anastasia Boulevard, a key gateway to downtown, say reliable parking is essential to capturing that holiday traffic.
The city has not publicly responded to the lawsuit. The case will now proceed through the courts, with the outcome potentially affecting how St. Augustine enacts future parking regulations and whether the expanded restrictions take effect as planned.