Local
Mother Sues Jacksonville Officer, City Over Fatal Shooting of Son During Mental Health Crisis
Melody Gissentanner filed a federal lawsuit Monday alleging JSO Officer Caleb Bumgarner used excessive force when he shot and killed her 30-year-old son, Gillis, as he ran away during a documented mental health crisis. The suit claims Gillis posed no imminent threat and disputes JSO's description of the knife he was carrying.
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. â The mother of a 30-year-old Jacksonville man shot and killed by a Jacksonville Sheriff's Office officer last year has filed a federal lawsuit against the officer and the city, alleging her son was gunned down from behind as he fled and posed no imminent threat.
Melody Gissentanner filed the suit Monday in federal court, naming JSO Officer Caleb Bumgarner and the City of Jacksonville as defendants. The complaint alleges Bumgarner used excessive and unjustified deadly force against her son, Gillis, who was experiencing a documented mental health crisis at the time of the Aug. 13, 2025, shooting.
According to the lawsuit, the encounter began when Gissentanner called JSO at 7:09 a.m. that morning asking officers to take her son into custody for a mental health evaluation under Florida's Baker Act. She reported that Gillis had damaged a neighbor's property overnight.
A JSO Behavior Crisis Response Unit officer and a licensed mental health clinician arrived at the family's home at 7:43 a.m. Gissentanner told them her son had a documented mental health history with the agency, including two prior Baker Act hospitalizations â one in 2018 and one in 2020. She also disclosed that Gillis may have suffered a traumatic brain injury years earlier after being accidentally shot in the face.
The neighbor whose property was damaged told officers she would handle the repairs herself. Asked what she wanted to happen to Gillis, she said, "I just want him to get some help."
While officers were still at the home, Gillis left on foot. Officers searched the neighborhood for more than an hour before Bumgarner spotted Gillis walking on a sidewalk several blocks away at 9:18 a.m.
According to the lawsuit, rather than waiting for backup or approaching Gillis calmly, the officer threatened him from his patrol vehicle, saying: "Come here or you're going to get dog bit."
The suit states that Gillis ran away. Bumgarner drove to catch up, exited his vehicle and drew his taser. The lawsuit and body camera footage released by JSO on Aug. 29, 2025, show Gillis briefly stopping, turning around holding a knife, saying "back up, back up," and then continuing to run away.
Bumgarner then holstered his taser, drew his firearm and fired, according to the account. JSO's body camera footage shows the officer firing six shots at Gillis as he ran away on East 25th Street near Buckman Street. Gillis fell to the sidewalk and died at the scene.
The lawsuit contends that at the moment Bumgarner opened fire, Gillis was running away and "had done nothing to put a reasonable police officer in fear of imminent death or great bodily harm." It further states that no other officers or people were in the area.
JSO described the knife Gillis was carrying as a "large, unsheathed knife." The lawsuit disputes that characterization directly, calling it "a common paring knife, with about a 3-inch blade."
JSO Chief Alan Parker, speaking the day of the shooting, said Gillis pushed the knife in Bumgarner's direction. "At that point, [Bumgarner] goes to lethal force," Parker said.
The lawsuit brings two counts: an excessive force claim alleging Bumgarner violated Gillis's Fourth Amendment rights, and a wrongful death claim under Florida law against the City of Jacksonville. The family is seeking compensatory damages, punitive damages and attorneys' fees.
Bumgarner had been with JSO for 11 years at the time of the shooting. It was his first officer-involved shooting. He is also among three officers named in a separate lawsuit alleging they violated a suspect's constitutional rights during a 2021 K-9 deployment that left the suspect with a fractured foot that became infected while he was in jail. The suspect's robbery charges were later cleared.
The case adds to growing scrutiny of how Jacksonville officers respond to people in mental health crises, particularly when a specialized crisis response team is already involved. Advocates have long argued that encounters involving people with documented psychiatric histories require de-escalation and patience rather than rapid escalation to lethal force.