Local
Jacksonville Orders Halt to Puerto Rico Coal Ash Shipments at Talleyrand Terminal
Jacksonville officials have ordered Keystone Properties to stop receiving coal ash from Puerto Rico and clear existing stockpiles within 45 days, citing missing permits and pollution risks. The move follows a lawsuit by the St. Johns Riverkeeper over the handling of more than two billion pounds of ash since 2022.
Jacksonville officials have ordered a halt to coal ash shipments from Puerto Rico at a Talleyrand-area terminal, citing the facility's lack of required permits and the potential hazard the material poses to local waterways and residents.
The city notified Keystone Properties LLC on November 16 that it had five days to stop receiving coal ash and 45 days to remove existing stockpiles from its 110-acre riverfront terminal at 1915 Wigmore Street. The order, signed by acting administrative services director Al Ferraro, carries a $2,000-per-day fine if the company fails to shut down its coal ash operation.
"My top priority as mayor is protecting the health, safety, and quality of life of all our residents," Mayor Donna Deegan said at a November 17 news conference. "Coal ash is not a benign material." Deegan noted that the ash commonly contains pollutants including mercury, cadmium and arsenic, and warned that "without proper management, it can pollute waterways, groundwater, drinking water, and the air."
The city's action follows an August lawsuit filed by the St. Johns Riverkeeper, which argued that Keystone has handled more than two billion pounds of coal ash since 2022 "without complying with many of the federal environmental safeguards governing those activities." Because Puerto Rico bans disposal of coal ash within its territory, the waste is shipped to Keystone's terminal and then hauled to a landfill in Folkston, Georgia.
City officials concluded that Keystone never obtained a "certificate of public convenience and necessity" required by city code to operate a solid waste management facility or transfer station. In an October letter, the city said such a transfer station is only allowed if the waste was generated within Duval County and approved by the City Council.
Keystone pushed back in a November 12 response, arguing that its terminal does not qualify as a transfer station because it primarily handles bulk shipments of cement, gypsum, wood chips and stone. "The primary purpose of the terminal is not to store or hold solid waste for transport ... as a transfer station," wrote environmental manager Bill Harris, so the certificate requirement does not apply.
A company representative said by email that Keystone employees "strive to comply with the city and responded to their notice from October. We do not believe the work being done at our Talleyrand facility requires this level of permitting, but we are working with the city to do what is necessary to resolve this issue."
Deegan said city law requires the City Council to hold a public hearing and vote on whether to issue the permit Keystone needs, but no hearing has been scheduled. John November, an attorney working with Riverkeeper, said coal ash can contain cancer-causing material and questioned what arguments could justify bringing such debris from another community to Jacksonville. He said Keystone handles other shipments that will not be affected by the city's order, and that Riverkeeper is only opposing the coal ash.
Separately, Riverkeeper and November's nonprofit law firm, Public Trust for Conservation, launched a website, keepcoalashout.com, to highlight the risks to the St. Johns River and to residents' health from the shipments.
Keystone has operated the riverfront terminal north of downtown for about 20 years. The city's order leaves open the possibility that coal ash shipments could resume if the company secures the required permit through a City Council vote, but for now the flow of ash from Puerto Rico has been stopped.