Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Jacksonville Focal

Jacksonville's independent voice

Local

Florida Executes Thomas Overton for 1991 Murders of Pregnant Teacher and Husband

Thomas Overton was executed Thursday for the 1991 rape and murder of a pregnant Florida Keys teacher and her husband, marking Florida's 20th execution of 2026 amid a record pace of death warrants under Gov. Ron DeSantis.

Florida Executes Thomas Overton for 1991 Murders of Pregnant Teacher and Husband

Florida executed Thomas Overton on Thursday for the 1991 rape and murder of a pregnant schoolteacher and her husband in the Florida Keys, the state's 20th execution of the year and the latest in an unprecedented surge of capital punishment under Gov. Ron DeSantis.

The U.S. Supreme Court denied Overton's request for a stay without comment earlier in the day, clearing the way for the execution. The court docket stated that the application was presented to Justice Thomas and referred to the full court, and that the petition for a writ of certiorari was denied.

Overton, who was sentenced to death in 1999, was convicted of breaking into the Tavernier home of Missy MacIvor, a teacher who was eight months pregnant, and her husband Michael MacIvor. According to testimony from fellow inmates, Overton admitted to surveilling the home before the attack, raping Missy MacIvor and strangling both victims. He also allegedly planted evidence to mislead investigators.

Overton met Missy MacIvor while working at a Florida Keys gas station in 1991. He was arrested for an unrelated burglary in 1996, and investigators obtained a DNA sample from blood on a towel after he cut his throat. The sample matched DNA from the crime scene. In addition to the death sentence for the murders, Overton received life sentences for sexual battery and burglary and 15 years for killing the unborn child.

Overton was one of the boys sent to the Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys in Marianna, a state-run reform school where abuse was so severe that the U.S. Department of Justice shut it down in 2011 following investigations into the suspicious deaths of at least 98 boys. The Florida Legislature apologized to survivors in 2017, and DeSantis signed legislation in 2024 providing millions in compensation.

At least 34 boys who stayed at Dozier, and another 16 sent to a similar school in Okeechobee, have since been sentenced to death, including Jesse Guardado, who was executed on Nov. 5.

"Florida failed Jesse Guardado and Thomas Overton when they were children in its custody," said Grace Hanna, executive director of the Florida Association for Death Penalty Alternatives. "The harm they later caused does not erase what the state did to them, or relieve Florida of its obligation to reckon with that abuse. Florida's acknowledgment of the abuse at Dozier must extend to mercy for the men who survived it."

Overton's execution is part of a dramatic escalation in Florida's use of the death penalty. DeSantis issued nine death warrants in the five years before 2025. Starting in February of that year, he issued 19, nearly three times the previous record of eight in a single year. So far this year, he has issued 23 death warrants, one of which was withdrawn. By comparison, there have been 18 executions in all other U.S. states combined this year.

DeSantis has said victims' families have waited long enough.

"I don't take joy in doing that; it's a weighty thing," DeSantis said on the day of a double execution on July 28. "Some of the victims' families have been waiting a long time, and some of them are just like, 'When are we going to get justice?'"

Florida death row inmates may request a last meal on the day of execution, but it must be locally sourced and cost under $40. Overton's request was not immediately disclosed. Past requests have ranged from lobster tail and fried shrimp to steak and eggs, or nothing at all.

More from The Jacksonville Focal