Tuesday, November 17, 2026·Focal News

The Indianapolis Focal

Indianapolis's independent voice

Politics

Judge Blocks Indiana Sen. Chris Garten's Seating as Democrats Challenge District 45 Results

A Southern Indiana judge issued a temporary restraining order preventing Republican Sen. Chris Garten from being sworn in for a new term, while also halting certification of the District 45 Senate race and the Clark County Auditor's race. The order comes as local Democrats sue over uncounted ballots from four precincts, setting up a high-stakes legal battle over election integrity in Clark County.

Judge Blocks Indiana Sen. Chris Garten's Seating as Democrats Challenge District 45 Results

A Southern Indiana judge has issued a temporary restraining order blocking Republican state Sen. Chris Garten from being seated for a new term representing District 45, as the Clark County Democratic Party pursues a legal challenge to his narrow victory. The order, granted Monday in Clark County, also prevents the county from certifying results for both the Indiana Senate District 45 race and the Clark County Auditor's contest.

The restraining order states that Garten is "restrained from presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45." A hearing on the Democrats' request for a preliminary injunction is scheduled for Wednesday.

The lawsuit, filed Monday by the Clark County Democratic Party, names the Clark County Election Board, Republican Clerk Ryan Lynch, and Garten as respondents. It seeks a preliminary injunction barring Garten from being sworn in until the Recount Commission makes a final determination, and asks the court to delay certification of the Senate District 45 results and the transmission of a certification statement to the state election division. The party also wants to block certification of the Clark County Auditor's race until that recount and contest are resolved.

The legal action follows a controversial decision by the Clark County Election Board last week. The board voted 2-1 not to count ballots from four precincts at the Jeffersonville High School polling place, where technical issues occurred on Election Day. The Democratic member of the three-person board, Andy Steele, voted against the resolution and, according to a party news release, "acknowledged on the record that the resolution adopted a false narrative."

Election results show Garten defeated Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 447 votes in Clark County, the largest area the district covers. Marshall edged out Garten in Floyd County, a smaller part of the district. In the Clark County Auditor's race, Republican Monty Snelling received 257 more votes than Democrat Antonio Veals.

"The Clark County Election Board left us with no other option but to resolve this issue in the courts," said Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton, Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian, and 9th District Indiana Democratic Party Chair Adam Dickey in a joint statement Monday. "Every person involved in this situation agrees there were significant issues with the election. The only disagreement is whether or not we should look into it."

Garten did not immediately respond to requests for comment Monday, but last week he characterized the Democrats' ballot concerns as "political theater."

The lawsuit asks for judicial review of the election board's Nov. 10 resolution, which found that the board had examined ballot sheets, poll pads, and precinct results, that the information was reconciled, and that it had no authority to open the ballot containers.

The Clark County Election Board met Friday to add provisional and military ballots. Angela Cornett, Clark County Voter Registration election administrator, said late Monday afternoon that the deadline to certify votes and send information to the state was Monday, but that results had not been certified.

The Indiana legislature convenes for Organization Day on Tuesday, when elected officials are sworn in. The Indiana Senate Majority Caucus recently selected Garten to serve as Senate President Pro Tem, though the Democratic caucus would have also had an opportunity to weigh in.

The deadline for candidates to file recount petitions is Tuesday at noon, while parties have until Friday.

Special Judge Jason Mount of Scott County is assigned to the Clark County case. Mount is a member of the volunteer Community Advisory Board for Indiana Public Broadcasting's local news partner, though that affiliation was not mentioned in the court order.

The dispute underscores growing concerns over election administration and access to the ballot in Southern Indiana. With control of a state Senate seat and a countywide office hanging in the balance, the case could have lasting implications for how contested elections are handled in the region.

More from The Indianapolis Focal