Local
Former Indiana Virtual School director convicted on all counts in $44 million enrollment fraud scheme
Philip Holden was found guilty of wire fraud and conspiracy for his role in inflating enrollment at Indiana Virtual School and Indiana Virtual Pathways Academy to siphon millions in state per-pupil funding. His conviction follows guilty pleas from the school's founder and former superintendent.
A federal jury on Thursday convicted Philip Holden, the former director of the Indiana Virtual School, on all 17 counts of wire fraud and one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud for his role in a scheme that inflated student enrollment to divert $44 million in state education funding.
Holden oversaw student enrollment, attendance, and teacher compensation at IVS and Indiana Virtual Pathways Academy, a related online school, according to the indictment. Prosecutors alleged that Holden, along with school founder Thomas Stoughton and former superintendent Percy Clark, reported inflated enrollment figures to the state to collect per-pupil funding, then funneled the money to for-profit companies owned by Stoughton and disbursed payments to Stoughton, Clark, and others.
The charges followed a 2017 investigation that revealed IVS had ballooning enrollment, just one teacher for every 222 students, and financial conflicts of interest. The findings prompted Indiana lawmakers to tighten funding and attendance requirements for virtual charter schools.
Two other men previously pleaded guilty in the case. Clark pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud in June 2025 and agreed to repay about $1.3 million. Stoughton pleaded guilty to fraud charges the day before a joint trial with Holden was set to begin.
Holden's defense attorney, Jon Little, characterized his client as a fall guy who did not financially benefit from the scheme. "My client did not take a dime," Little told Chalkbeat on Friday. "My client is not even alleged to have taken a dime. My client was only paid for his labor."
The U.S. attorney's office for the Southern District of Indiana did not immediately return a request for comment.
Holden is scheduled to be sentenced on Feb. 25.
The case has drawn attention to oversight of Indiana's virtual charter schools, which receive state funding based on enrollment. IVS and Indiana Virtual Pathways Academy abruptly closed in fall 2019 amid the state investigation and the resignation of the schools' board members and other staff.