Politics
Federal Judge Holds ICE in Contempt for Rearresting Released Immigrant, Declines Sanctions After Policy Halted
U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney found ICE in contempt of her release order after agents re-detained a Wyoming man minutes after his court-ordered release, but stopped short of sanctions because the agency ended the practice once she began investigating.
A federal judge in Denver held U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in contempt of court on Wednesday for violating her order to release an immigrant from detention, but declined to impose penalties because the agency halted the practice after she launched an inquiry.
U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney, a Biden appointee, issued a sharply worded order finding that ICE officials in Colorado violated her directive by immediately re-arresting Ramon Quintero Alvarez of Wyoming, who had been held at the privately run Aurora detention center. The case is one of a flood of habeas corpus petitions that have overwhelmed Colorado's federal trial court, recently surging to roughly 100 per week.
"Sometimes, behavior stuns and renders a listener speechless," Sweeney wrote in her Nov. 18 order. Quoting the Supreme Court, she added: "The government of the United States has been emphatically termed a government of laws and not of men."
The case began when Quintero Alvarez filed a habeas petition seeking release. The U.S. Attorney's Office did not contest the petition, triggering his automatic release under a unique case-processing agreement the office had with the district court at the time. But on Nov. 3, Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrew Soler told Sweeney that Quintero Alvarez had been released, immediately re-detained, and remained in custody.
"It appears to me we have a problem of monumental importance," Sweeney said at a follow-up hearing. "We are now in a situation where this court's order, and the orders of other judges of this court, are frankly being made a mockery of. And that cannot be. This gentleman was ordered released, period. There was no take-him-out-to-the-hallway-and-let's-do-this-process-again."
Nichole Black, the assistant ICE field office director for Denver, testified that she "received a direct order" from acting director Nathan Rasper "to re-detain habeas releases that had some kind of criminality." Rasper later told Sweeney that Black's representation was "overly compressed" and that he had rescinded the directive after the judge began asking questions.
In her order, Sweeney found that ICE clearly violated her order by re-arresting Quintero Alvarez. She noted that Black had testified that Quintero Alvarez was subject to immediate re-arrest because he had pending criminal charges, but that Black later agreed it was "fair" to say she had inaccurate information about any current pending charge.
Sweeney wrote that Black's testimony that she believed she was complying with court orders by carrying out the immediate re-arrest "should â and, in the Court's opinion, must â shock any reader." She added: "There is not a single word in this Nation's Constitution that sustains or could plausibly give rise to Ms. Black's 'belief' that ICE and ICE agents can walk out to the sidewalk and re-shackle a habeas petitioner within a minute of that petitioner's court-ordered release."
The judge acknowledged that Rasper believed Black had misunderstood his instructions, which Sweeney characterized as an effort to throw Black "under the proverbial bus for unconstitutional behavior that runs top to bottom." But Sweeney described the re-detention policy as aimed at thwarting judges' release orders.
While Sweeney considered formal contempt proceedings, other judges in Colorado moved to guard against any resumption of the re-arrest policy. Judge Philip A. Brimmer took the unusual step of telling ICE it may not re-arrest a habeas petitioner "without advance notice to this Court" citing ICE's legal authority to re-detain. Senior Judge R. Brooke Jackson indicated he would consider ICE employees in contempt if they re-arrested a petitioner.
"'Release' means 'release and let go,' not release and rearrest," Jackson wrote in a Monday order.
Sweeney found Black in contempt of her orders, but because ICE complied by ending the immediate re-arrest practice, she did not impose sanctions. "The single thing" that saved Colorado ICE officials from penalties, she wrote, was the decision to cease the policy after she began investigating.
ICE and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Separately, Judge Nina Y. Wang is exploring ICE's practice of imposing conditions of release on petitioners that judges have not ordered. The case-processing agreement between the U.S. Attorney's Office and the district court, which triggered automatic releases when the government did not respond to petitions, was pulled by the office earlier this month.
The ruling comes as Colorado's federal courts face an unprecedented volume of immigration detention challenges, with petitioners contesting bond denials, the adequacy of bond hearings, and conditions ICE has unilaterally imposed on their release. The contempt finding underscores growing judicial frustration with the agency's defiance of court orders, even as the judge stopped short of punitive measures.