Politics
Colorado's Tax Competitiveness Plummets After Voters Approve Graduated Income Tax
A new Tax Foundation analysis projects Colorado will fall to 44th nationally in tax competitiveness following the passage of Amendment 87, which replaces the state's flat income tax with six brackets. Supporters argue the ranking ignores quality-of-life factors and that lawmakers must now focus on how new revenue is spent.
Colorado's standing as a tax-friendly state has taken a sharp hit after voters approved a sweeping overhaul of the income tax system, according to a new analysis. The state would drop to No. 44 nationally under its new graduated income tax structure, down from No. 33 before the election, the Tax Foundation found in an analysis prepared for a local news outlet.
The decline follows the passage of Amendment 87, a voter-approved measure projected to raise $2.7 billion by increasing taxes on households and businesses earning more than $500,000 while modestly reducing bills for most other taxpayers. The amendment replaces Colorado's flat 4.4% income tax with six brackets ranging from 3.7% to 8.4%. It passed with 52% support, according to final vote tallies, while a competing measure to cap income tax rates at the current 4.4% was rejected.
The shift would place Colorado among the nation's least tax-competitive states, alongside Massachusetts, New Jersey, California and New York, per the foundation's rankings, which favor lower taxes and simpler tax codes. For years, Colorado's flat income tax and low 2.9% sales tax helped its standing, though high business property taxes and a patchwork of local levies kept it in the middle of the pack.
"With the adoption of a high graduated-rate income tax, Colorado will rank below-average on every component of the index except the corporate tax component," Jared Walczak, a senior fellow at the Tax Foundation, said.
The downgrade marks another blow for Colorado's once-strong business standing, which has also slipped in other national rankings. But supporters of Amendment 87 pushed back on the foundation's methodology, arguing it fails to capture what makes Colorado attractive.
"The Tax Foundation's top states for competitiveness are Wyoming and South Dakota â both because they have no individual or corporate income taxes. I'll put Colorado's quality of life, ability to start, operate and grow a business, or raise a family up against Wyoming and South Dakota any day," said Kathy White, a leader on the Amendment 87 campaign. "An index that doesn't reflect that should be taken with a grain of salt."
The foundation updates its rankings annually, and Colorado's final standing could shift depending on tax changes in other states. Meanwhile, attention is turning to how lawmakers implement the new tax structure and spend the additional revenue â decisions that could affect the state's status in other categories, such as healthcare and education outcomes.
"If we're going to be competitive, what do we do from here?" said Henry Sobanet, treasurer of the Colorado State University System, at a post-election briefing. "Performance and effectiveness of how the money is spent is going to be the coins of the realm."