Local
Aurora Nears End of Consent Decree, Finalizes Leadership for New Police Oversight Office
Aurora community members met with three finalists for the new Office of Public Safety Accountability as the city's five-year consent decree is set to expire in 2027. The finalists emphasized rebuilding trust, but some residents remain skeptical about the office's power and community input.
AURORA, Colo. â As Aurora's five-year consent decree approaches its end, the city moved closer to establishing a new police oversight office on Monday, hosting a public meet-and-greet with three finalists for the top leadership role.
The Office of Public Safety Accountability, created by a City Council ordinance in June, will monitor and review complaint investigations and critical incidents, including police use of deadly force. It will also establish a liaison for families involved in such incidents. The consent decree, agreed to by Attorney General Phil Weiser and Aurora officials following the 2019 death of Elijah McClain, is expected to expire in 2027.
About 20 community members attended the event at the Aurora Municipal Center, where the finalists â John Hummel, Eric Williams, and Shenandoah Titus â each pitched their vision for the office. A common theme was rebuilding trust between law enforcement and the community.
"This community, the city could easily say, 'High five, mission accomplished. We got through the consent decree. We did it.' This has to be viewed as the start," said Hummel, an attorney at a Denver personal injury firm and former Oregon district attorney. "Improving policing is a constant process."
Williams, a Aurora native and current deputy vice president of investigations for the U.S. Center for SafeSport, stressed the need for a culture shift. "From a use of force standpoint, from just directly acknowledging that there has been bias when it comes to specific persons who have been encountered by police, those are areas of focus that you're not going to cure those issues overnight," he said. Williams previously served as deputy director of Denver's Department of Public Safety and held leadership roles at the FBI.
Titus, who runs his own consulting firm, Counsel of Police Oversight USA, and worked at the Department of Homeland Security from 2012 to 2018, emphasized balance and managing expectations. "I am not a sit-behind-the-desk kind of public servant. I will be out there with the community," he said. "This office is no one's avenger."
But not everyone was convinced. Cassandra Heil, a community member who spoke with all three finalists, expressed skepticism that the office would bring meaningful change. "I am very skeptical. I do not trust these people at all," she said. "There's not much power that the community has in it."
Arapahoe County Commissioner Rhonda Fields, who attended the event, said the community has felt dismissed. "The community doesn't feel like it's heard or respected. There's been numerous occasions where the community input and feedback was not considered," Fields said. "There's some tension there that needs to be addressed."
Kiawa Lewis, whose brother Kilyn Lewis was fatally shot by an Aurora police officer in 2024, said he wants someone who understands the pain of victims' families. He was hopeful about Williams. "He wasn't somebody who actually seemed to want to uphold the police, regardless if they're in the wrong or not," Lewis said.
For months, Lewis and other activists have demanded the firing of Aurora Police Chief Todd Chamberlain. None of the finalists voiced support for firing Chamberlain, saying they would need to consult with community groups. Titus said he intentionally avoided researching Chamberlain to maintain an open mind. "If there are public safety officials in the city of Aurora who are not doing their job properly and taking care of the civil and human rights of all persons within the city of Aurora, then they are going to have issues," he said.
The consent decree has been overseen by an independent monitor, which published reports on the police and fire departments' compliance with mandated reforms. The new office is seen as a key part of sustaining those reforms after the decree ends.
The city is expected to announce its selection for the office's manager in the coming weeks.